Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have become the cornerstone of nucleic acid delivery platforms, particularly in RNA-based vaccines and therapeutics. However, the conventional methods of LNP production, which are primarily reliant on microfluidic mixing of aqueous and organic solvent phases, pose limitations in terms of mRNA stability, residual organic contamination, scalability, cost, and environmental impact. These limitations prompted a renewed search for non-conventional strategies with the promise of improving mRNA-LNP encapsulation approaches. These emerging approaches aim to address key bottlenecks, including mRNA hydrolysis-driven degradation, high production losses, and complex downstream purification. Moreover, the ability to decouple LNP synthesis from mRNA encapsulation could enable streamlined, modular manufacturing workflows and customizable payload delivery, including single- or multiple-mRNA payloads, thereby expanding the therapeutic scope of LNPs. This review offers an early insight into the design principles and scalability potential of emerging non-conventional LNP encapsulation approaches, including solvent-free and microfluidics-free methodologies, and pre-built LNP workflows. We also examine trends in emerging LNP encapsulation tools, including high-shear mixing, sonication, membrane contraction, and other approaches. Finally, we extrapolate the suitability of the methods for scale-up approaches and their economic implications based on the process information.
Zhang et al. (Sun,) studied this question.