We report the influence of stellar mass on black hole mass in galaxies, suggesting distinct environments for AGNs and non-AGNs.
We investigate the relation between supermassive black holes (SMBHs), their host galaxies, and large-scale dark-matter halos by combining broad-line X-ray active galactic nuclei (AGNs) from the XMM--XXL and Stripe,82X surveys with galaxies from VIPERS and SDSS/Stripe,82. Building on the homogeneous host-galaxy catalogue developed in Paper I, we test whether AGNs with a given black-hole mass, M_̊m BH, occupy the same or different large-scale environments as non-AGN galaxies with statistically indistinguishable host properties. We characterised the empirical M_̊m BH--M_⋆ distribution of the AGN sample. A shallow scaling between M_̊m BH and stellar mass, M_⋆, is present, but with a large intrinsic scatter influenced by flux-limited selection and virial-mass uncertainties. The ratio ̊m BH /M_⋆ declines with increasing M_⋆ over the sampled range. Overmassive and undermassive AGN subsets, defined relative to this empirical trend, exhibit distinct median host properties consistent with partially non-synchronous SMBH and M_⋆ growth. We then selected AGNs in two M_̊m BH intervals, 8.0 łe łog(M_ ̊m BH /M_⊙) < 8.5 and 8.5 łe łog(M_ ̊m BH /M_⊙) < 9.0, and constructed galaxy control samples matched in M_⋆, SFR, and sSFR ($= $) using a multivariate nearest-neighbour procedure. Using AGN--galaxy cross-correlation functions, we inferred characteristic halo masses for AGNs and matched galaxies in each bin. The AGNs with 8.0 łe łog(M_ SFR M_⋆ ̊m BH /M_⊙) < 8.5 occupy halos statistically indistinguishable from those of their controls, indicating no detectable environmental dependence at these masses once host properties are controlled. In the higher-mass bin, 8.5 łe łog(M_ ̊m BH /M_⊙) < 9.0, we find a mild indication that AGNs may reside in more massive halos than the matched non-AGN galaxies. The inferred difference is sim0.4,dex but remains formally consistent within the uncertainties. If confirmed with larger samples, this may indicate that halo-scale processes become increasingly relevant only at the highest M_̊m BH, while at lower masses AGN environments remain indistinguishable from those of inactive galaxies with similar host properties.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mountrichas et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: