Long-Term Outcome of Total and Near-Total Resection of Spinal Cord Lipomas and Radical Reconstruction of the Neural Placode, Part II

OBJECTIVE: To show the long-term benefits of total and near-total resection of complex spinal cord lipomas and reconstruction of the neural placode. METHODS: We analyzed 238 patients with dorsal, transitional, and chaotic lipomas who had total resection as described in part I for overall progression-free survival probability (PFS, Kaplan-Meier analysis) over 16 years. We also analyzed subgroup proportional recurrence hazard (Cox analysis) of 6 outcome predictors of sex, lipoma type, age, preoperative symptoms, previous surgery, and postoperative cord-sac ratio. These results were compared with an age-matched, lesion-matched series of 116 patients followed for 11 years after partial lipoma resection and with the Parisian series of nonsurgical treatment. RESULTS: The immediate effects of surgery were similar between total and partial resection: both achieved greater than 95% symptom stabilization or improvement rate. The neuro-urologic complication rates for the groups were also similar, 4.2% and 5.2% for total and partial resection, respectively. The combined cerebrospinal fluid leakage and wound complication rate of total resection was much lower at 2.5% than the 6.9% for partial resection, but both were better than published rates. The overall PFS for total resection was 82.8% at 16 years, comparing much more favorably with 34.6% for partial resection at 10.5 years (P 50%, and a 3-fold increase in recurrence hazard for high ratios (P = .0009). This suggested that all the individual effects of the other predictor variables could be reduced to whether a low cord-sac ratio could be achieved with total lipoma resection and placode reconstruction. Cord-sac ratio was the obvious factor that differentiated the outcomes between total and partial resection, the latter associated with a >90% chance of having a high cord-sac ratio. CONCLUSION: Total and near-total resection of lipomas and complete reconstruction of the neural placode produced a much better long-term progression-free probability than partial resection and nonsurgical treatment. The perioperative complications for total resection were low and compared favorably with published results. A low postoperative cord-sac ratio and well-executed placode neurulation were strongly correlated with good outcome. The ideal preoperative patient profile with early disease stabilization and the best recurrence-free probability is an asymptomatic child less than 2 years without previous lipoma surgery. There are strong indications that partial resection in many cases produces worse scarring on the neural placode and worse prognosis than no surgery.