Compares activity-based and cost-based methods for assessing carbon emissions in Indonesia, highlighting discrepancies and implications for construction practices.
The construction industry is a significant contributor to global greenhouse gas emissions, primarily through energy-intensive activities during the construction phase. This study investigated the carbon dioxide emissions associated with flexible road pavements by comparing activity- and cost-based calculation methods. The activity-based approach incorporates detailed equipment activity data, considering variations in equipment conditions, whereas the cost-based method relies on generalised emission factors linked to project costs. The results revealed significant discrepancies between the two methods, with the activity-based approach reporting substantially higher emission values. For example, the emissions for the wearing course (AC-WC) layer were 6 659 kgCO2 for activity-based calculations compared to only 443 kgCO2 for cost-based estimates. Such underestimations by the cost-based method demonstrate its inadequacy in accurately capturing construction emissions. Furthermore, the cement-treated base layer was identified as the largest contributor to emissions in activity-based analyses, contradicting the cost-based method’s attribution of the highest emissions to the AC-Base layer. This study emphasises the importance of using activity-based approaches for carbon accounting in road construction to ensure accurate assessments and inform sustainable construction practices. Policymakers are encouraged to adopt region-specific, activity-based methods to enhance carbon accounting accuracy and guide effective environmental policies for road construction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Suwondo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: