Elucidating the Bell-Shaped Dependence of Protein Translation Activity on EF-Tu Concentration in a Reconstituted Cell-Free System Using a Mechanistic Model

Protein synthesis in cell-free protein synthesis systems often exhibits nonintuitive input–output relationships. In the PURE system, a reconstituted cell-free system, protein production peaked at low elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) concentrations and decreased at higher concentrations, resulting in a characteristic bell-shaped profile. Here, we investigated the origin of this behavior using a detailed mechanistic model of translation in the PURE system, designated as ePURE, which describes the reaction dynamics of hundreds of molecular species and reactions. Our computational analysis suggested that excess EF-Tu sequesters the initiator tRNA (tRNAfMet) into nonproductive EF-Tu·GTP·Met-tRNAfMet complexes, thereby depleting the pool of initiator tRNA available for translation initiation. This suppression arises from competition for a limited molecular resource rather than from direct inhibition. Based on this mechanism, we predicted that increasing the concentrations of tRNAfMet and methionyl-tRNA formyltransferase would eliminate the bell-shaped dependence, and experimentally confirmed this prediction. Under these modified conditions, the bell-shaped response disappeared and protein production was enhanced. These findings demonstrate how mechanistic computational models can reveal hidden constraints underlying nonintuitive input–output relationships in complex biochemical networks and guide the rational optimization of cell-free protein synthesis systems.