From ‘evil influence’ to social facilitator: representations of youth smoking, drinking, and citizenship in Canadian health textbooks, 1890–1960

One route to uncovering schooling’s goals for an improved citizenry is to track certain subjects of the compulsory curriculum. In this case, health is investigated, and especially its messages on smoking and drinking. First introduced as scientific temperance instruction (in the 1880s), renamed hygiene (from about 1910), then as health (from the mid‐1920s), and expanded to encompass as well physical education and personal development from the mid‐1940s, health curricula were an important vehicle for turning impressionable youth into personally and socially responsible citizens. An explication of the Ontario (Canada) health curriculum between 1890 and 1960 provides an insight into the changing official prescription of the good citizen. It also shows how changed notions of health in the modern age are from the 19th‐century antecedents, and, especially, how self‐interest has become central to that definition. Accordingly, the lessons around smoking and drinking have moved from these products being an ‘evil influence’ to one of social facilitation. Keywords: character educationcitizenship educationhealth educationOntario educationtextbook analysis Acknowledgement I thank Tim Cook and Ken Montgomery for their important research support for this paper; the Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa, for its support of my research into Canadian anti‐tobacco campaigns; and Kathleen Imrie, Special Collections Librarian at the Hodgins Room, Ontario Institute of Education of the University of Toronto, Canada. Notes 1. E.g. Clark (1995 Clark, P. 1995. ‘Take it Away, Youth!’: Visions of Canadian Identity in British Columbian Social Studies Textbooks, 1925–1989, Vancouver, BC, , Canada: University of British Columbia. Doctoral thesis [Google Scholar]), Davis (1992 Davis, R. 1992. The Idea of Progress and the Meaning of Canada in the High School History Curriculum, Toronto, Ontario, , Canada: University of Toronto. Doctoral thesis [Google Scholar]), Montgomery (2005a Montgomery, K. 2005a. ‘A Better Place to Live’: National Mythologies, Canadian History Textbooks and the Reproduction of White Supremacy. Doctoral thesis, Ottawa, Ontario, , Canada: University of Ottawa. [Google Scholar]), Osborne (1980 Osborne, K. W. 1980. ‘Hard‐working, Temperate and Peaceable’—The Portrayal of Workers in Canadian History Textbooks, Monographs in Education IV, Edited by: Gregor, A. and Wilson, K. Winnipeg, MB: University of Manitoba. [Google Scholar], 1998 Osborne, K. 1998–1999. One hundred years of history teaching in Manitoba schools: Part I: 1897–1927. Manitoba History, 36(Autumn/Winter): 3–25. [Google Scholar]–1999, 2001 Osborne, K. 2001. [Voices from the past] Where are the ancient pieties and loyalties of the race? A 1923 Report on the teaching of civics. Canadian Social Studies, 36(1) Available on‐line at: http://www.quasar.ualberta.ca/CSS/CSS_36_1/index36_1.htm, accessed 25 June 2006 [Google Scholar]), and Sodonis (2005 Sodonis, M.‐A. 2005. Discourse and Politics of Canadian History Curriculum Documents Used in Ontario Secondary Schools, 1945–2004. Doctoral thesis, Toronto, Ontario, , Canada: University of Toronto. [Google Scholar]). 2. For an insightful analyses of the role played by health discourses in the construction and constitution of the idealized Canadian child’s body in this period, see Gleason (2001 Gleason, M. 2001. Disciplining the student body: schooling and the construction of Canadian children’s bodies, 1930–1960. History of Education Quarterly, 41(2): 189–215. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]). 3. In their tightly argued analysis of Christianity’s on‐going influence in the new social welfare network, Christie and Gauvreau (1996 Christie, N. and Gauvreau, M. 1996. A Full‐Orbed Christianity: The Protestant Churches and Social Welfare in Canada, 1900–1940, Kingston and Montreal: McGill‐Queens University Press. [Google Scholar]) demonstrate the pivotal nature of the 1920s in re‐fashioning notions of social reform. 4. For more explanation of temperance ideas, and especially those of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, the largest non‐denominational women’s organization devoted to health and hygiene, see Cook (1994 Cook, S. A. 1994. ‘Earnest Christian women, bent on saving our Canadian youth’: The Ontario Woman’s Christian Temperance Union and scientific temperance instruction, 1881–1930. Ontario History, 86(3): 249–267. [Google Scholar], 1995b Cook, S. A. 1995b. ‘Sowing seed for the master’: The Ontario WCTU and evangelical feminism 1874–1930. Journal of Canadian Studies, 30(3): 175–194. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]). 5. Only elementary school textbooks were authorized for health instruction in Ontario until the mid‐1940s, when textbooks recommended for grades 9 and 10 were also listed in Circular 14, the government‐produced list of acceptable textbooks for all subjects in Ontario’s schools. 6. For smoking, see Cook (2001 Cook, S. A. 2001. “Evangelical moral reform: women and the war against tobacco, 1874–1900”. In Religion and Public Life in Canada: Historical and Comparative Perspectives, Edited by: Van Die, M. 177–195. Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), and Rudy (2005 Rudy, J. 2005. The Freedom to Smoke: Tobacco Consumption and Identity, Kingston and Montreal: McGill‐Queen’s University Press. [Google Scholar]). For drinking, see Noel (1995 Noel, J. 1995. Canada Dry: Temperance Crusades Before Confederation, Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), Cook (1995a Cook, S. A. 1995a. ‘Through Sunshine and Shadow’: The Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, Evangelicalism, and Reform in Ontario, 1874–1930, Kingston and Montreal: McGill‐Queen’s University Press. [Google Scholar]), and Gusfield (1996 Gusfield, J. R. 1996. Contested Meanings: The Construction of Alcohol Problems, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press. [Google Scholar]). 7. For tobacco, see Cox (1989 Cox, H. 1989. Growth and ownership in the international tobacco industry: BAT 1902–27. Business History, 31(1): 44–67. [Taylor & Francis Online] , [Google Scholar]), Cunningham (1996 Cunningham, R. 1996. Smoke & Mirrors: The Canadian Tobacco War, Ottawa, ON: International Development Research Centre. [Google Scholar]), Kruger (1996 Kruger, R. 1996. Ashes to Ashes: America’s Hundred‐Year Cigarette War, the Public Health, and the Unabashed Triumph of Philip Morris, New York: Knopf. [Google Scholar]), Tate (1999 Tate, C. 1999. Cigarette Wars: The Triumph of ‘The Little White Slaver’, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]), and White (1988 White, L. 1988. Merchants of Death: The American Tobacco Industry, New York: Beech Tree Books. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]). 8. See also Gately (2002 Gately, I. 2002. La Diva Nicotina: The Story of How Tobacco Seduced the World, London: Scribner. [Google Scholar]), Greaves (1996 Greaves, L. 1996. Smoke Screen: Women’s Smoking and Social Control, Halifax, NS: Fernwood. [Google Scholar]), Hughes (2003 Hughes, J. 2003. Learning to Smoke: Tobacco Use in the West, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar]), Segrave (2005 Segrave, K. 2005. Women and Smoking in America, 1880–1950, Jefferson, NC: McFarland. [Google Scholar]), and Tinkler (2003 Tinkler, P. 2003. Refinement and respectable consumption: the acceptable face of women’s smoking in Britain, 1918–1970. Gender & History, 15(2): 342–360. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]). 9. See Epstein (1981 Epstein, B. L. 1981. The Politics of Domesticity: Women, Evangelism, and Temperance in Nineteenth‐Century America, Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press. [Google Scholar]: 107), Heron (2003 Heron, C. 2003. Booze: A Distilled History, Toronto, ON: Between the Lines. [Google Scholar], 2005 Heron, C. 2005. The boys and their booze: masculinities and public drinking in working‐class Hamilton, 1890–1946. Canadian Historical Review, 86(3): 411–452. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), Rorabaugh (1979 Rorabaugh, W. J. 1979. The Alcoholic Republic: An American Tradition, New York: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]: 189), and Warsh (1993 Warsh, C. K. 1993. “‘John Barleycorn must die’: an introduction to the social history of alcohol”. In Drink in Canada: Historical Essays, Edited by: Warsh, C. K. 3–26. Kingston and Montreal: McGill‐Queen’s University Press. [Google Scholar]). 10. See, e.g. Nattress (1893 Nattress, W. 1893. Public School Physiology and Temperance, Toronto, ON: William Briggs. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), the authorized textbook for Ontario from 1893. 11. For example, see Watson (n.d.), published about 1895. Following chapters on the skeleton and nutritional needs of the body, Watson devotes a long chapter to ‘Alcohol’ (pp. 84–95), but nothing separately to tobacco. 12. See also Henderson and Fraser (1897 Henderson, G. E. and Fraser, C. G. 1897. Physiology and Hygiene Notes, Toronto, ON: Educational Publishing. [Google Scholar]). 13. The same information was repeated in textbooks over the next several decades; see, e.g. Solandt (1933 Solandt, D. Y. 1933. Highways to Health, Toronto, ON: The Ryerson Press. [Google Scholar]: 86). Solandt’s textbook was recommended for use in grades 7 and 8 from 1934. 14. Several other provincial departments of education produced films in 1921, including Alberta and Saskatchewan. This suggests the existence of a federal programme with grants to support citizenship education on film. 15. National Library Archives Canada, films produced by the Ontario Department of Education, all 1921. For example, ‘Hot Lunches for Rural Schools’ and ‘The Educational Playgrounds’. 16. The same argument continued to be used throughout this period: It has been found that there is a 10% loss in muscular energy 1 hour after a person drinks 2–6 ounces of whisky. Thus it appears that athletic ability is affected by even moderate amounts of alcohol. (Phair and Speirs 1958 Phair, J. T. and Speirs, N. R. 1958. Good Health Today, Toronto, ON: Ginn. [Google Scholar]: 318) Note the inappropriate alcoholic drink of reference: even during the 1950s, whisky was assuredly not the drink of choice of young men, athletes or otherwise. 17. The 1920s textbook offered an environmental analysis of these products, citing the many ‘indirect’ effects. These included spending too much on alcohol and tobacco and too little on proper housing, food, and education, and the general weakening of the system, giving rise to opportunistic illness. See, e.g. Fraser and Porter (1925 Fraser, D. T. and Porter, G. D. 1925. Ontario Public School Health Book, Toronto, ON: Copp Clark. [Google Scholar]: 103). 18. This is not to say that young men or women who did not fit the model of Canadian youth were entirely ignored. Rather, they were ignored as smokers. For example, Solandt (1933 Solandt, D. Y. 1933. Highways to Health, Toronto, ON: The Ryerson Press. [Google Scholar]: 84–85) addresses girls on general health issues, as do later texts, including particularly Phair and Speirs (1958 Phair, J. T. and Speirs, N. R. 1958. Good Health Today, Toronto, ON: Ginn. [Google Scholar]: vii), which notes ‘that 70% of a girl’s health interests in Grade Ten revolve around concern for her personal appearance’, and yet nothing appears in the book on the girl smoker or her appearance‐related reasons for choosing to smoke. 19. For his extended and insightful discussion of a number of parallel minor vices, including smoking, drinking, swearing, illicit drugs, gambling, and sexual misbehaviour, see Burnham (1993 Burnham, J. C. 1993. Bad Habits: Drinking, Smoking, Taking Drugs, Gambling, Sexual Misbehavior, and Swearing in American History, New York: New York University Press. [Google Scholar]), especially the introduction (pp. 1–22). 20. Even pre‐war textbooks noted the health dangers of smoking and alcohol to young men. See, e.g. MacMurchy and Auden (1911 MacMurchy, H. and Auden, H. W. 1911. Simple Rules of Health and Courtesy for Those at School, Toronto, ON: Cassell. [Google Scholar]: 7–8), which offers children a wide range of briefly stated ‘rules of health’, from ‘Never touch alcoholic liquor, except under a doctor’s orders’, to ‘Never swallow cherry stones, etc.’ or ‘Do not smoke, at any rate till you are 21 years old. Infinite harm is done to heart and nerves by premature smoking’. However, the link with cancer was untraced. 21. At the same time, various anti‐tobacco texts had made the link between smoking and cancer far earlier than 1964, though their assertions lacked the credibility of the scientific and medical communities. See, e.g. ‘General Grant and Emperor Frederick of Germany, who were both great and good men, nevertheless smoked so much that it gave them cancer of the throat from which they died’ (Guerber 1932 Guerber, H. A. 1932. Yourself and Your House Wonderful, Toronto, ON: John C. Winston. [Google Scholar]: 227). 22. Medical authorities could easily be found who linked disease with smoking, especially in males; see, e.g. Goldsmith (1929 Goldsmith, W. M. 1929. Human Poisons: Individual and Racial Effects, Winfield, KS: William M. Goldsmith. [Google Scholar]), especially ‘Medical men speak’ (pp. 47–53). However, although the 1919 Report of the US Surgeon‐General had put the case of the probable relationship between smoking and cancer, the link was only accepted by the US medical establishment in 1964. 23. For example, in Solandt’s textbook (1933 Solandt, D. Y. 1933. Highways to Health, Toronto, ON: The Ryerson Press. [Google Scholar]: 94–111), an entire chapter is provided for ‘The battle against disease’, with a major section devoted to combating disease, and another to curing. In neither does ceasing smoking or drinking make an appearance. On cancer, it notes, ‘Very little is known about the cause of cancer. The disease occurs mostly in middle‐aged and old people, and unless the growth is removed early by surgery it will kill the patient’ (p. 111). 24. In Shacter et al. (1951b Shacter, H., Jenkins, G. D. and Bauer, W. W. 1951b. You’re Growing Up, Guidebook, Toronto, ON: W. J. Gage. [Google Scholar]), e.g., no line is drawn between these adolescent concerns and tobacco use. See especially pp. 110–122. 25. See also Phair and Speirs (1958 Phair, J. T. and Speirs, N. R. 1958. Good Health Today, Toronto, ON: Ginn. [Google Scholar]: 334–339). For an almost identical message, see Nicoll et al. (1958 Nicoll, J. S., Foster, J. C. and Bolton, W. W. 1958. Your Health Today and Tomorrow, River Forest, IL: Laidlaw. [Google Scholar]: 177–178). 26. As in all cases, however, there are exceptions to this rule. The popular US textbook, For Healthful Living (Jones et al. 1950 Jones, E., Morgan, E. and Landis, P. E. 1950. For Healthful Living, River Forest, IL: Laidlaw. [Google Scholar]), frequently reprinted, continued with the old grouping with such narcotics as heroin, marijuana, and opium, and allows two paragraphs to tobacco (pp. 44–45). A second frequently reprinted textbook by the same authors, Your Health and You (Jones et al. 1949 Jones, E., Morgan, E. and Landis, P. E. 1949. Your Health and You, River Forest, IL: Laidlaw. [Google Scholar]), intended for the pre‐adolescent student, groups tobacco with other drugs, and is so careful in its claims that it is patently unconvincing to either boys or girls. For example, ‘It may make the heart beat faster and over‐work. It may have a bad effect on the throat and lungs. It may affect the nerves of young people. Tobacco may take away a person’s appetite for proper foods. Then the person would lose weight and strength’ (pp. 295–296). 27. ‘The classification of alcohol with habit‐forming drugs like morphine or opium is also misleading. These drugs bring about physical changes in the body tissues which create a craving for the drug. Alcohol does not work in this way’ (Phair and Speirs 1951 Phair, J. T. and Speirs, N. R. 1951. Good Health, Toronto, ON: Ginn. [Google Scholar]: 325–326). 28. For 2001, see Canadian Survey (2001 Canadian Survey. 2001. Canadian Tobacco Use Monitoring Survey for 2001 Available on‐line at: http://www.hc‐sc.gc.ca/hecs‐sesc/tobacco/research/ctums/2001/summary.html, accessed 18 May 2006 [Google Scholar]).