Evidence of Highly Conserved β-Crystallin Disulfidome that Can be Mimicked by In Vitro Oxidation in Age-related Human Cataract and Glutathione Depleted Mouse Lens*

Low glutathione levels are associated with crystallin oxidation in age-related nuclear cataract. To understand the role of cysteine residue oxidation, we used the novel approach of comparing human cataracts with glutathione-depleted LEGSKO mouse lenses for intra- versus intermolecular disulfide crosslinks using 2D-PAGE and proteomics, and then systematically identified in vivo and in vitro all disulfide forming sites using ICAT labeling method coupled with proteomics. Crystallins rich in intramolecular disulfides were abundant at young age in human and WT mouse lens but shifted to multimeric intermolecular disulfides at older age. The shift was ∼4x accelerated in LEGSKO lens. Most cysteine disulfides in β-crystallins (except βA4 in human) were highly conserved in mouse and human and could be generated by oxidation with H2O2, whereas γ-crystallin oxidation selectively affected γC23/42/79/80/154, γD42/33, and γS83/115/130 in human cataracts, and γB79/80/110, γD19/109, γF19/79, γE19, γS83/130, and γN26/128 in mouse. Analysis based on available crystal structure suggests that conformational changes are needed to expose Cys42, Cys79/80, Cys154 in γC; Cys42, Cys33 in γD, and Cys83, Cys115, and Cys130 in γS. In conclusion, the β-crystallin disulfidome is highly conserved in age-related nuclear cataract and LEGSKO mouse, and reproducible by in vitro oxidation, whereas some of the disulfide formation sites in γ-crystallins necessitate prior conformational changes. Overall, the LEGSKO mouse model is closely reminiscent of age-related nuclear cataract. Low glutathione levels are associated with crystallin oxidation in age-related nuclear cataract. To understand the role of cysteine residue oxidation, we used the novel approach of comparing human cataracts with glutathione-depleted LEGSKO mouse lenses for intra- versus intermolecular disulfide crosslinks using 2D-PAGE and proteomics, and then systematically identified in vivo and in vitro all disulfide forming sites using ICAT labeling method coupled with proteomics. Crystallins rich in intramolecular disulfides were abundant at young age in human and WT mouse lens but shifted to multimeric intermolecular disulfides at older age. The shift was ∼4x accelerated in LEGSKO lens. Most cysteine disulfides in β-crystallins (except βA4 in human) were highly conserved in mouse and human and could be generated by oxidation with H2O2, whereas γ-crystallin oxidation selectively affected γC23/42/79/80/154, γD42/33, and γS83/115/130 in human cataracts, and γB79/80/110, γD19/109, γF19/79, γE19, γS83/130, and γN26/128 in mouse. Analysis based on available crystal structure suggests that conformational changes are needed to expose Cys42, Cys79/80, Cys154 in γC; Cys42, Cys33 in γD, and Cys83, Cys115, and Cys130 in γS. In conclusion, the β-crystallin disulfidome is highly conserved in age-related nuclear cataract and LEGSKO mouse, and reproducible by in vitro oxidation, whereas some of the disulfide formation sites in γ-crystallins necessitate prior conformational changes. Overall, the LEGSKO mouse model is closely reminiscent of age-related nuclear cataract. Aging lens crystallins accumulate post-synthetic modifications that can be broadly classified into three categories, namely (1) protein backbone changes, such as racemization and truncation (1.Lampi K.J. Shih M. Ueda Y. Shearer T.R. David L.L. Lens proteomics: analysis of rat crystallin sequences and two-dimensional electrophoresis map.Invest. Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 2002; 43: 216-224PubMed Google Scholar, 2.Lampi K.J. Wilmarth P.A. Murray M.R. David L.L. Lens beta-crystallins: the role of deamidation and related modifications in aging and cataract.Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 2014; 115: 21-31Crossref PubMed Scopus (89) Google Scholar, 3.Asomugha C.O. Gupta R. Srivastava O.P. Structural and functional roles of deamidation of N146 and/or truncation of NH2- or COOH-termini in human alphaB-crystallin.Mol. Vision. 2011; 17: 2407-2420PubMed Google Scholar), (2) conversion of one amino acid into another, such as deamidation of asparagine into aspartate or deguanidination of arginine into ornithine, deamination of lysine into allysine and 2-aminoadipic acid (4.Hooi M.Y. Raftery M.J. Truscott R.J. Racemization of two proteins over our lifespan: deamidation of asparagine 76 in gammaS crystallin is greater in cataract than in normal lenses across the age range.Invest. Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 2012; 53: 3554-3561Crossref PubMed Scopus (55) Google Scholar, 5.Fan X. Sell D.R. Zhang J. Nemet I. Theves M. Lu J. Strauch C. Halushka M.K. Monnier V.M. Anaerobic vs aerobic pathways of carbonyl and oxidant stress in human lens and skin during aging and in diabetes: A comparative analysis.Free Radical Biol. Med. 2010; 49: 847-856Crossref PubMed Scopus (58) Google Scholar, 6.Sell D.R. Monnier V.M. Conversion of arginine into ornithine by advanced glycation in senescent human collagen and lens crystallins.J. Biol. Chem. 2004; 279: 54173-54184Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (56) Google Scholar), and (3) amino acid residue damage from reactive carbonyls and reactive oxygen species (7.Ahmed N. Thornalley P.J. Dawczynski J. Franke S. Strobel J. Stein G. Haik G.M. Methylglyoxal-derived hydroimidazolone advanced glycation end-products of human lens proteins.Invest. Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 2003; 44: 5287-5292Crossref PubMed Scopus (220) Google Scholar,8.Bhattacharyya J. Shipova E.V. Santhoshkumar P. Sharma K.K. Ortwerth B.J. Effect of a single AGE modification on the structure and chaperone activity of human alphaB-crystallin.Biochemistry. 2007; 46: 14682-14692Crossref PubMed Scopus (29) Google Scholar). Carbonyl damage results from the Maillard Reaction by glucose, methylglyoxal, or oxidation products of ascorbate, tryptophan or lipids which form adducts and crosslinks with nucleophilic group of lysine, arginine and cysteine. Examples include carboxymethyl-lysine, pentosidine, methylglyoxal adducts and (7.Ahmed N. Thornalley P.J. Dawczynski J. Franke S. Strobel J. Stein G. Haik G.M. Methylglyoxal-derived hydroimidazolone advanced glycation end-products of human lens proteins.Invest. Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 2003; 44: 5287-5292Crossref PubMed Scopus (220) Google of of in lens PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, Sell D.R. M. Ortwerth B.J. Monnier V.M. protein crosslinks and oxidation in human lens and Sci. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, Truscott R.J. of to proteins in the human lens. A role in age-related nuclear PubMed Scopus (56) Google Scholar, R. Y. Sharma S. P.J. S. and of the of the glutathione of in human lens Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 2003; 44: PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). damage results from reactive oxygen species that damage amino acid tryptophan into and into and cysteine into cysteine disulfides or acid J. D.R. in of the tryptophan as a of PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, oxidation of cysteine and in normal and Sci. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, disulfides in human PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). of to age-related the of of modifications on crystallin structure and is the of that used cysteine used cysteine crystallin the of are needed in for lens to be of the of protein in the normal human lens by Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 17: Google of of the PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). by one of that include conformational changes as a amino acid Truscott R.J. analysis of the oxidation of cysteine in human age-related nuclear cataract Biophys. PubMed Scopus Google or protein the one that is in of cataract oxidation of into protein disulfides Truscott R.J. analysis of the oxidation of cysteine in human age-related nuclear cataract Biophys. PubMed Scopus Google and formation of that of lens protein in vivo using in a model for nuclear PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). glutathione cysteine lens acid acid glutathione cysteine lens acid acid In to the and formation of protein disulfides to of glutathione in the of the human we the LEGSKO mouse in which was by the cysteine X. X. S. Monnier V.M. The LEGSKO a mouse model of age-related nuclear cataract based on of lens glutathione 2012; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). nuclear cataract by and model for the of that or the oxidation of crystallin and protein in on the sites of disulfide formation are in mouse and human age-related cataract. To we the comparative analysis of the cataract LEGSKO mouse and human aging and lens crystallin and the results with the disulfidome from mouse lens in vitro with as a model of crystallin and were in with by the and to the for of in and were and to and Lens cysteine mouse were as by and as LEGSKO mouse X. X. S. Monnier V.M. The LEGSKO a mouse model of age-related nuclear cataract based on of lens glutathione 2012; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). human used for was by young normal human at and of and three normal human at and of age were from the of The lenses were young and normal lens were to as for all human cataract lenses were from and in was based on Lens The lenses were and were three lenses in The age of group was and the was and the was and and the was and cataract lenses were to The lens was in acid with and on for The lens was at for at and the was three with and for at of was then in ICAT and and on for The was for in during The was in at for by at the was and protein was using method The was then in human lenses in were in and then to for ICAT labeling and LEGSKO mouse cataract and age lenses were as X. Strauch C. R. Ortwerth B.J. Monnier V.M. aging of lens crystallins by the Maillard in a mouse Sci. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar), and using the as for human that the lens was used than the of lenses were to as for LEGSKO cataract mouse lens protein in and of proteins and by at for at by for was in a with or or of at to was by the of at using a and of were and with of with the was at for on The was three with and at for The was then in of ICAT with and the as for human and mouse lens by of protein of lens as was with of and at for at for the was with and then for in a The were in ICAT with and at for in The were then with the ICAT at for in the as in the human cataract and LEGSKO mouse cataract lens were with ICAT whereas the young human and mouse lens were with the ICAT a of or cataract lens with was to which was To the of was into were at for in the by of of and for at in the The was to by acid and then with and acid with The were by using with The were and by and with acid with and The were with a and the was by the with The were then to analysis at the for The of to the ICAT was in with then by and by The from was and with acid with The from were with normal and from and cataract were with to S. S. G. J. The in of method to 2011; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). a of or cataract lens with was and the from was and using as In of of and oxidation of and the shift of and at and were as modifications for of labeling The of to modification was by of on of were as the of the for analysis of the was with coupled with a The were in the by of a in at and on the abundant in with the of The of was with and the were human The was at for and for of as as the oxidation of was as and ICAT with the shift of and were identified using and then by for the and with and of ICAT labeling was using The of ICAT to ICAT was and on of for The for the but with and oxidation were then the but with and the was by the from the was in the from sites was from and were from three ICAT were identified with the and The to the R. N. P.A. I. M. G. R.J. S. R. and 2014; PubMed Scopus Google the with the and analysis for intra- and intermolecular disulfide analysis was as electrophoresis for the of proteins with Sci. PubMed Scopus Google with some In the lens was in acid and the was in and on for with of of for three The protein in was by protein of of was to protein protein was to and to electrophoresis in the for at using a the the proteins were and in for at a with the were in for was then to and electrophoresis was in the for at were in acid for and with to the were in and three were in age were with in and the protein was with at for by the using for in the The were and the were with and in in The were then in in for from the with in acid were in and then in analysis was by using a coupled with The were by of a and on the abundant at the of were identified by on with A of two were for and was at and was used for the of mouse The was to with at two at were to be were as analysis was to in in D.R. Monnier V.M. of skin collagen glycation and in J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). In of in was by or of were electrophoresis and analysis we the of which proteins are associated with intra- versus intermolecular in normal versus young human and with in LEGSKO mouse lens. the ICAT labeling to all disulfides and to we then the novel of crystallin disulfides in human cataracts with in glutathione-depleted LEGSKO mouse cataracts and mouse lens proteins in vitro The protein disulfide formation in young and human lenses was using two-dimensional then The of the of is in The to the protein which age-related shift of protein associated with intramolecular disulfides of the to proteins associated with intermolecular disulfide crosslinks of the proteins are for the The of in by is in from and normal lens are in of protein disulfides are as intramolecular disulfides at of the intramolecular disulfide protein and than intermolecular disulfide protein were whereas in human than intramolecular disulfide and than intermolecular disulfide proteins were analysis using and that the of proteins in the disulfide crosslinks of the were a shift in was in the versus young WT mouse and In the intra- to intermolecular disulfide shift at in the LEGSKO mouse lens with the WT lens In the LEGSKO lens to intermolecular disulfide protein and over intramolecular disulfide protein In one to two intramolecular disulfide proteins and than were as intermolecular disulfide crosslinks at accelerated the aging of the lens proteins as by the shift from intra- to intermolecular disulfide by analysis was to the of in in into two A and on are highly with or The of is in and all human were in the intramolecular disulfide of the include human and γD, normal mouse lenses and and γD, and was and mouse to human the on the intermolecular disulfide of human and LEGSKO lens based on the in and which we based on protein are in I. γD, were in all and which was in in crosslinks from to and were from and and were with in the crystallin were in than in are to forming In LEGSKO mouse, γD, were in all and in and was in to and to human was in in in we to intermolecular disulfide the disulfide of the LEGSKO mouse and human lens of the protein of the protein in from a human and LEGSKO mouse lens identified in the intermolecular disulfide of the are in all are in and are in are in are in all are in and are in are in are in all are in and are in are in are in all are in and are in are in γD, γD, γD, are in all are in and are in are in in a of cysteine were identified based on to oxidation with age and as a of and of cataract from to The cysteine that are with age and in the cysteine with oxidation in normal lenses but in cataracts of cataract the cysteine with oxidation in normal lenses and in cataract and the cysteine that are with age but in cataracts, and associated with cataract The from ICAT labeling and analysis are in and the protein based on labeling is in cysteine such as in in γD, in and in with oxidation, than in normal and cataract lenses with young of cysteine such as in disulfide formation with young lenses of of and in young which is from the crystal structure of was than in normal lens but was in cataract lenses crystal structure that is to the one of the for intermolecular disulfide cysteine such as in γD, and in in and in are in normal but are in cataracts, of and some cysteine such as in and in oxidation over in cataract cysteine oxidation in cataract lenses with in to structure that is that cysteine are and protein is for disulfide be in the we into of cysteine and then at of two cysteine that cysteine are role in of cysteine Cys33 in in and in oxidation during aging but was in cataract and was associated with of cataract that cysteine are and for disulfide and be during cataract conformational Most we cysteine oxidation was in normal human lens but in cataract. Cys154 in was in cataract but was in in Cys115, and Cys130 in oxidation to in cataract lenses with young and were in cataracts, and Cys33 in oxidation in to cataract but was in and cataract lenses and we two cysteine and in that were in cataract lenses structure that is by and some protein is in for to be in intermolecular disulfide lens glutathione mouse and with age-related human nuclear cataract X. X. S. Monnier V.M. The LEGSKO a mouse model of age-related nuclear cataract based on of lens glutathione 2012; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). LEGSKO mouse lens crystallins a age-related shift in protein disulfide crosslinks as in we to the oxidation of cysteine as in human we used ICAT and for LEGSKO cataract lens were with age mouse lens In the β-crystallin and in were and two with lenses to human cataract mouse was to oxidation, by we oxidation in LEGSKO cataract cysteine residue which is to and to βA4 Cys33 and were and in human cataract lenses was of with as βA4 and the of oxidation of in LEGSKO than human cataract human and mouse βA4 crystallin but oxidation was in was highly to oxidation during aging as as and were and to age lenses a amino acid as human at that human a single cysteine residue in and were and closely the of the human lens. In the γ-crystallin mouse and were and and was in human and LEGSKO whereas oxidation was in human lens. Cys33 and oxidation was in human cataract and Cys130 were and which closely the human with which was in human γS. Cys154 in in and in were in LEGSKO cataract lenses as in is oxidation sites of β-crystallins mouse and and some To the the disulfide formation and crystallin we mouse lens to or in at to to for in vitro is during acid oxidation M. Ortwerth B.J. The of by the of human lens PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, M. Ortwerth B.J. of the reactive oxygen species generated by the of lens PubMed Scopus Google Scholar), and lens of acid of in and PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). of the was by at in the lens was to oxidation during the and and with at and H2O2, protein was in lens the as and which was with and and as and which was with and the protein disulfide using the ICAT method with of the H2O2, as and ICAT cysteine in disulfide crosslinks in of crystallins cysteine in lens crystallins were into disulfide oxidation by for disulfide crosslinks were in highly lens with oxidation were at in and in in but oxidation from and and could be into crystallin in that in all three crystallins are to oxidation but be stress at oxidation and as as oxidation of the identified cysteine were at to lens but was oxidation that cysteine are to stress but to a be that is was needed of oxidation was at some cysteine residue oxidation and disulfide formation sites were associated with oxidation and such as in in in in and in crystallins The role of cysteine oxidation into disulfides in the of age-related cataract a of for protein of in human 17: PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, protein associated with human Sci. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). is a in the of age-related cataracts, in nuclear The in vivo modifications of the human lens crystallins are disulfide oxidation and backbone PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, of crystallins associated with human lens Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. Google Scholar, R.J. nuclear is the PubMed Scopus Google based on that crystallin disulfide crosslinks are associated with aging and cataract formation in human lens formation in the Sci. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). disulfides in human PubMed Scopus Google Effect of and on human lens protein and Google a of disulfides with aging and cataract. The of of cysteine oxidation into disulfides was by and disulfide in human lens PubMed Scopus Google X. Y. modifications of human lens crystallins from young Biol. Chem. Full Text PDF PubMed Google and in the intramolecular disulfide of crystallin during aging of the human PubMed Scopus Google formation of and of crystallin during of the human PubMed Scopus Google of intramolecular disulfide in human using Truscott Truscott R.J. analysis of the oxidation of cysteine in human age-related nuclear cataract Biophys. PubMed Scopus Google analysis of cysteine using and acid method in three and human cysteine disulfide crosslinks were in Truscott that the of a model was to of the role of oxidant stress in R.J. nuclear is the PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). we generated the LEGSKO mouse levels are associated with lens at X. X. S. Monnier V.M. The LEGSKO a mouse model of age-related nuclear cataract based on of lens glutathione 2012; PubMed Scopus Google and are the of the changes in LEGSKO mouse are with of human and can be with in the of was generated in all three to we a comparative which to the that the LEGSKO mouse human disulfide formation sites in β-crystallins and of in The comparative of crystallin oxidation sites is in In sites in were in were of cysteine oxidation sites into disulfides in human normal human LEGSKO mouse and LEGSKO mouse lens with sequences are using for residue in than in young A the that oxidation was The oxidation was is the the and the is a sequences are using for residue in than in young A the that oxidation was The oxidation was is the the and the is of cysteine were cysteine that are to oxidation with age and (2) cysteine that are to oxidation with age and in cataract lenses of (3) cysteine that are to oxidation with age and associated with of and cysteine that are with age but are in cataract lenses and with the of cataract. results are in with Truscott R.J. analysis of the oxidation of cysteine in human age-related nuclear cataract Biophys. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). our cysteine in crystallins that are in disulfide formation with some we cysteine in or in but we cysteine in and crystallin that were in disulfide The was in which oxidation with aging and was in cataract in human and LEGSKO cataract is and in In was with age but was in whereas was in human In our we oxidation in and cataract lenses and in cataract that and are to oxidation stress results from of in a of in cysteine in that we human cataract lens from we in and Cys33 in βA4 were with age and with whereas in were associated with cataract. we in was in lens and but in and cataracts, whereas is associated with cataract. the the two lenses were used in could be the for the some of the the two In that the ICAT method is highly and of S. S. J. in vivo cysteine oxidation in proteins using ICAT and 2014; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). in vitro and in vivo that cysteine are during the aging or in vitro The formation of intermolecular disulfide the into and are the role in cysteine oxidation, such as the and of amino available crystal structure we can some of cysteine oxidation from that the is are and in in which all are to the and for intermolecular disulfide The be the of crystallin Examples are in Cys33 in in and Cys130 in in which cysteine is conformational expose cysteine in to form intermolecular disulfide is by in which is and conformational cysteine can then that of cysteine oxidation in aging and lens is by (1) amino in the and the and (2) and of cysteine to the and (3) conformational and of of age-related that oxidation or The lens as with of glutathione and acid and are in human in the lens Effect of on glutathione in as as of human PubMed Scopus Google Truscott R.J. to glutathione in older normal human a for nuclear PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). mouse with human in age-related nuclear that the mouse crystallins form disulfide crosslinks to human lens aging and cataract In LEGSKO cataract and in Cys33 and in and Cys130 in and in γD, and in and in were all in with the from human cataract In LEGSKO cataract we to Cys154 oxidation in whereas we in human mouse a single cysteine residue and human two cysteine and our is that and are as intramolecular Cys154 is to oxidation in the mouse, ICAT approach is to intermolecular disulfide in the intramolecular disulfide of crystallin during aging of the human PubMed Scopus Google a of and Cys154 can be used to oxidation that was in human but LEGSKO mouse cysteine to crystallin we cysteine oxidation in human but was in mouse and are conserved human and is in human and as in two cysteine and were in mouse but all by in and human in βA4 was in human but in LEGSKO mouse of βA4 crystallin as in that βA4 is the form in mouse lens. cysteine oxidation were in and crystallins but in human in is to one of human amino but and and crystallin was in human lens. two to be the formation of disulfides is for the and the of disulfidome is in the of the ICAT used in the of cysteine oxidation sites for and is the of in our we are systematically of the cysteine oxidation sites in to roles in to all modifications in the aging and human lens. the for in lens is that the LEGSKO mouse lens and the crystallins in and with of cysteine disulfide are that tryptophan oxidation to be systematically as by Truscott Truscott R.J. of to proteins in the human lens. A role in age-related nuclear PubMed Scopus (56) Google Scholar), we are to understand is to the than cysteine the disulfidome is that the used in the ICAT labeling modifications prior to with the ICAT is to be highly for disulfides J. G.M. of disulfide by Chem. Scopus Google Scholar). our include but some of the the of which is in the lens R. of lens protein disulfides by PubMed Scopus Google activity of and modifications of or was to our of and by Biol. 17: PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, S. S. J. of on the activity and structure of group PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). was to the to of protein acid in Google Scholar, and for PubMed Scopus Google Scholar), as as of with PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). that are highly to be to the species by the ICAT used in protein in in vitro S. of by of PubMed Scopus (58) Google Scholar), in acid is modification in the is that be to the by the that we used for the ICAT and for PubMed Scopus Google M. changes in the stress in Sci. PubMed Scopus Google acid and in and J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). the modification is during in vitro or protein oxidation with of with PubMed Scopus Google M.J. R.J. form with Biol. Chem. Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus Google Scholar), but to our in In all cysteine oxidation sites identified by the ICAT can be to the in the of In our and comparative disulfide analysis of a age-related shift from intra- to intermolecular disulfide formation in and human and that oxidation sites with of some sites in γ-crystallins are mouse and Most of sites can be by in vitro the the formation of disulfides and to be In that the LEGSKO mouse as a mouse model for of the cysteine oxidation and Zhang at for and for of with