Key result
GPS instructions caused the second largest time-percentage of stress state among driving events, lower than turning but higher than waiting for traffic lights and other traffic conditions.
Why the study?
Although GPS is thought to reduce stress in unfamiliar road conditions, whether GPS instructions reduce or induce additional mental stress during driving remained unclear.
Do GPS instructions induce additional mental stress in automobile drivers compared to other driving events?
Observational
Do GPS instructions induce additional mental stress in automobile drivers compared to other driving events?
GPS instructions may induce significant mental stress in drivers, contrary to the common belief that they alleviate stress.
GPS instructions may heighten driver stress; hypothesis-generating for navigation design and requires prospective validation.
It is commonly known that Global Positioning System (GPS) can alleviate travelling difficulties of automobile drivers, and generally we hold the view that it reduces the driver's stress when they are in unfamiliar road conditions. In this research, an in-laboratory experiment and an in-car experiment are conducted to find out whether GPS instructions can reduce or may induce additional mental stress of drivers. Electrocardiography (ECG) signals are collected in the experiments and the extracted heart rate variability (HRV) features are used for analysis. Three binary classifiers, specifically Support Vector Machine, k-Nearest Neighbor (k-NN) and Random Forest, are trained based on the data collected in the in-laboratory experiment, where the stress state is elicited by the Stroop color word Test. The k-NN classifier outperforms the other two classifiers, and thus is applied to the data collected in the in-car experiment, to identify drivers' stress state under different driving events, such as waiting for traffic lights, turning, under GPS instructions, and traffic conditions like overtaking, or changing lanes. During each event, whether the driver is in stress or relaxed state for each time instant is predicted based on the trained classifier. The percentages of time that the driver is in stress state for each type of events are computed. It shows that GPS instructions cause the second largest time-percentage of stress state, lower than that caused by the turning event, but higher than that caused by the events of waiting for traffic lights and other traffic conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Li et al. (2020) conducted an observational in Mental stress in drivers. GPS instructions vs. Other driving events (turning, waiting for traffic lights, overtaking, changing lanes) was evaluated on Percentage of time in stress state. GPS instructions caused the second largest time-percentage of stress state among driving events, lower than turning but higher than waiting for traffic lights and other traffic conditions.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: