Reconsidering medication‐free research in early‐episode schizophrenia prompts a review of acute psychosocial treatments using medication postponement protocols. We describe and compare the different psychosocial treatment approaches. Studies were included in the review if initial psychosocial treatment combined with a time‐limited postponement of antipsychotics was compared to initial antipsychotic treatment using a quasi‐experimental or better research design and reported outcomes of at least one year. Five studies were included (N=261), each reporting modestly better long‐term outcomes than initial medication treatment, resulting in a composite small–medium effect‐size advantage (r = 0.17). In addition, 27–43% of experimental patients were not receiving antipsychotics at the two‐ or three‐year follow‐up. These projects demonstrate the feasibility of a carefully supervised approach to medication‐free research and also suggest a strategy for integrating biological, psychological and social treatment components in early‐episode psychoses. Initial psychosocial treatment combined with a time‐limited postponement of antipsychotic medications for eligible, non‐dangerous, early‐episode patients may facilitate a reduction in long‐term medication dependence and the discrimination of similar but pathophysiologically different diagnostic entities. Rigorous evaluation in a randomized controlled trial designed to identify medication and psychosocial treatment‐responsive subgroups of patients may contribute to diagnostic specificity and improved patient outcomes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bola et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: