Adaptation, Ecological Impacts, and Risk Assessment: Insights from Research at Foundry Cove, Bayou Trepagnier, and Pass Fourchon

This paper takes a detailed look at the occurrence of genetic adaptations and ecological impacts at three contaminated sites (Foundry Cove, Bayou Trepagnier, Pass Fourchon) to assess the co-occurrence of adaptation and ecological impacts and the implications for risk assessment. Community-level ecological impacts were reported for all three sites. However, there was little evidence of population-level impacts (on the six populations that were also assessed for adaptation). Similarly, adaptation was found in only one of the populations. While this review provides an incomplete picture (adaptation was assessed on only a small subset of the species present and the reasons behind the lack of adaptation in the five populations remained unknown), it indicates that adaptation is uncommon even where ecological impacts are obvious. Theoretical considerations also predict that contaminants can have large impacts without resulting in an adaptation. While adaptation to a contaminant reflects an impact by that contaminant, the three case studies indicate that determining whether or not resistance has evolved does not appear to be a very efficient tool for detecting ecological impacts. Nevertheless, assessing the occurrence of adaptation does have a place in risk assessment, especially when assessing the likelihood of local extinction of a particular population Keywords: adaptationecological impactrisk assessmentevolution of resistanceimplications