Surgical versus Nonsurgical Treatment of Ligamentous Injuries Following Dislocations of the Elbow Joint

Sixty-two patients older than 16 years of age at the time of injury were reexamined an average of five years (range, 1 to 12 years) after a dislocation of the elbow without concomitant fracture. Thirty-four were treated nonsurgically with closed reduction and immobilization in a plaster cast. Twenty-eight were treated surgically with primary ligament repair followed by immobilization in plaster. Ligament repair was performed medially in all cases and laterally in 17, on the average two days after injury. At follow-up examination, the most common complaint in both groups was limited range of motion, decreased extension being the most common. In no respect were the surgically treated elbows better than those treated nonsurgically. No evidence was found to recommend primary surgical treatment of ligament injuries associated with dislocation of the elbow.