A Molecular Reexamination of Introgression Between Helianthus Annuus and H. Bolanderi (Compositae)

Heiser (1949) hypothesized that a weedy race of Helianthus bolanderi had originated by the introgression of genes from H. annum into a serpentine race of H. bolanderi. Although Heiser's investigation of these species is frequently cited as one of the best examples of introgression in plants, definitive evidence of gene exchange is lacking (Heiser, 1973). To determine whether the weedy race of H. bolanderi actually originated via introgression, we analyzed allozyme, chloroplast-DNA (cpDNA), and nuclear-ribosomal-DNA (rDNA) variation. Evidence from enzyme electrophoresis did not support the proposed introgressive origin of weedy H. bolanderi. We detected a total of 37 low-frequency alleles distinguishing the serpentine race of H. bolanderi from H. annuus. Weedy H. bolanderi possessed only four of the 37 marker alleles. Further analysis demonstrated that serpentine H. bolanderi combined seven of the 35 alleles distinguishing H. annuus from weedy H. bolanderi, indicating that serpentine H. bolanderi shares three more marker alleles with H. annuus than does weedy H. bolanderi. These results are similar to expectations for race divergence from a single common ancestor and suggest that, if introgression occurred, the majority of marker alleles were rapidly lost following the initial hybridization event. Even more compelling evidence opposing Heiser's (1949) hypothesis, however, was from restriction-fragment analysis of cpDNA and nuclear rDNA. We detected a total of 17 cpDNA and five rDNA restriction-site mutations among the 19 populations examined. No parallel or back mutations were observed in phylogenetic trees constructed using either cpDNA or rDNA mutations, and both phylogenies were completely congruent regarding the alignment of all three taxa. In addition, the weedy race of H. bolanderi possessed a unique cpDNA, which was outside the range of variation observed among populations of either of the presumed parental species. Mean sequence divergences between the cpDNAs of weedy H. bolanderi and those of serpentine H. bolanderi and H. annuus were 0.30% and 0.35%, respectively. These estimates are comparable to sequence-divergence values observed between closely related species in other plant groups. Given the lack of parallel or convergent mutations in the cpDNA and rDNA phylogenetic trees, the complete congruence of these trees with flavonoid- and allozyme-variation patterns, and the presence of a unique and divergent chloroplast genome in the weedy race of H. bolanderi, we suggest that the weedy race of H. bolanderi was not derived recently through introgression, as hypothesized, but is relatively ancient in origin.