Differential Expression of the Myocyte Enhancer Factor 2 Family of Transcription Factors in Development: the Cardiac Factor BBF-1 Is an Early Marker for Cardiogenesis

In the present study, we have used single chicken blastoderms of defined early developmental stages, beginning with the prestreak stage, stage 1 (V. Hamburger and H. L. Hamilton, J. Morphol. 88:49-92, 1951), to analyze the onset of cardiac myogenesis by monitoring the appearance of selected cardiac muscle tissue-specific gene transcripts and the functional expression of the myocyte enhancer factor 2 (MEF-2) proteins. Using gene-specific oligonucleotide primers in reverse transcriptase PCR assay, we have demonstrated that the cardiac myosin light-chain 2 (MLC2) and alpha-actin gene transcripts appear as early as stage 5, i.e., immediately after the cardiogenic fate assignment at stage 4. Consistent with this observation is the developmental expression pattern of DNA-binding activity of BBF-1, a cardiac muscle-specific member of the MEF-2 protein family, which also begins at stage 5 prior to MEF-2. Differential expression of DNA-binding complexes is also observed with another AT-rich DNA sequence (CArG box) as probe, but the binding pattern with the ubiquitous TATA-binding proteins remains unchanged during the same developmental period. Thus, the cardiogenic commitment and differentiation of the precardiac mesoderm, as exemplified by the appearance of cardiac MEF-2, MLC2, and alpha-actin gene products, occur earlier than previously thought and appear to be closely linked. The onset of skeletal myogenic program follows that of the cardiogenic program with the appearance of skeletal MLC2 at stage 8. We also observed that mRNA for the MEF-2 family of proteins appears as early as stage 2 and that for CMD-1, the chicken counterpart of MyoD, appears at stage 5. The temporal separation of activation of cardiac and skeletal MLC2 genes, which appears immediately after the respective fate assignments, and those of cardiac MEF-2 and CMD-1, which occur before, are consistent with the established appearance of the myogenic programs and with the acquisition pattern of the two tissue-specific morphological characteristics in the early embryo. The preferential appearance of BBF-1 activity in precardiac moesderm, relative to that of MEF-2, indicates that these two protein factors are distinct members of the MEF-2 family and provides a compelling argument in support of the potential role of BBF-1 as a regulator of the cardiogenic cell lineage determination, while cardiac MEF-2 might be involved in maintenance of the cardiac differentiative state.