Transparent Surfaces and Illuminated Holes

A single stimulus determined the alternative perceptions of an illusory transparent grey disk or of an internally illuminated circular hole. A square on a far background was visible through this disk or hole. Subjects rated the grey colour of the transparent disk or the phenomenal illumination inside the hole. The luminance difference relative to the transparent disk and the square and that relative to this disk and its background determined the probability of perceiving the transparent disk or the hole. Rated colour and illumination substantially depended only on this second difference. These results have implications for models of phenomenal transparency and illumination based on the idea that proximal contours activate neural representations of phenomenal attributes.