Why the study?
Does sodium amytal sedation threshold differentiate neurotic from psychotic depression?
Does sodium amytal sedation threshold differentiate neurotic from psychotic depression?
Sodium amytal sedation thresholds may help differentiate between neurotic and psychotic depression.
May differentiate neurotic from psychotic depression subtypes; Level 5 evidence leaves open any diagnostic role.
There are conflicting psychiatric opinions about the value of separating depressive illnesses into several syndromes on clinical grounds, and so far experimental attempts to reach a classification of depression by distinguishing physiological or biochemical features which characterize one group rather than another have had only limited success. One interesting series of experiments in this area has been that of Shagass and his colleagues on the sedation threshold (Shagass et al. , 1956, Shagass and Naiman, 1956, Shagass, 1954); they report that neurotic and psychotic depressions can be differentiated by means of EEG and other reactions to sodium amytal (amylobarbitone sodium) neurotics requiring greater amounts of the drug to reach the sedation threshold.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Martin et al. (1962) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 3 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: