Are land bird assemblages functionally saturated? An empirical test in Mexico

According to the model of ideal free distribution, few or no assemblages will contain unused resources as long as species are free to colonize areas where resources are available. Consequently, because several food resources for birds are available throughout Mexico (nectar, seeds and fruits, vertebrates, carrion and different types of invertebrates), we predicted that all assemblages from Mexico contain birds from the corresponding foraging guilds. However, severe climates may prevent colonization by certain birds. Thus, a second prediction was that, if assemblages with unused resources were found, these would be from localities with climates that pose extreme stress (either extremely high temperature and low rainfall, or extremely low temperature). We tested these predictions on bird assemblages from 77 localities that represent the entire range of climatic conditions found in Mexico. Only two assemblages containing unused resources were found. These were from the localities with lowest temperature and lowest rainfall, respectively. We observed that land bird assemblages in Mexico do not contain unused resources, except when climate selectively restricts colonization by species from certain foraging guilds. Therefore, we conclude that even assemblages with almost no species in common have a common guild structure based on food resources. Null models of competition would be more realistic if they were to incorporate such patterns in their regional species pools.