Segment-Based Multi-Criteria Dynamic Assessment of the Rational Applicability of Decarbonization Technologies to Commercial Fishing Vessels

The sustainable development of all economic sectors, including transport, requires decarbonization approaches that reduce greenhouse-gas emissions while preserving operational viability. This article develops a segment-based preliminary multi-criteria framework for evaluating the rational applicability of decarbonization technologies to commercial fishing vessels and demonstrates it for existing medium-to-large trawlers. The central premise is that decarbonization technologies cannot be ranked universally for the whole fishing fleet because vessel type, fishing gear, operating cycle, autonomy, onboard energy demand, and port dependence strongly affect practical applicability. Ten alternatives are assessed: sustainable drop-in biofuels/biodiesel/HVO (Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil), LNG/BioLNG/LBG, methanol, hydrogen fuel cells, ammonia, hybrid systems, operational measures, hull-form or hydrodynamic modifications, waste heat recovery and wind-assisted propulsion. Seven benefit-type criteria are combined using trawler-specific Rank-Order Centroid weights, Simple Additive Weighting, and a dynamic rationality extension for 2026, 2030, 2040, and 2050. The 2026 baseline results place operational measures and sustainable drop-in biofuel/HVO pathways in the leading practical group, while hydrogen and ammonia remain weak because of storage, safety, infrastructure, cost, and integration constraints. By 2050, a mixed long-term group emerges where HVO, LNG/BioLNG/LBG, methanol, ammonia, and hydrogen are all relevant, with no single dominant alternative. The framework supports early-stage screening before vessel-specific LCA, LCCA, CFD, safety assessment, and retrofit or newbuild design. Although this methodological approach was demonstrated for existing medium-to-large trawlers, the authors believe that it can be adapted for retrofit cases, other fishing vessel segments, and other types of seagoing vessels.