Active psychological stress (PASAT) and passive stress (IAPS) both increased circulating IL-6 and SIRI, with no significant difference in inflammatory response magnitude between tasks (p>0.05).
RCT (n=88)
Randomized order
Does an active stress task compared to a passive stress task elicit different cardiovascular and inflammatory responses in human participants?
Both active and passive psychological stressors provoke similar systemic inflammatory responses, despite active stress causing greater cardiovascular reactivity.
valor p: p=>0.05
OBJECTIVE: Acute psychological stress is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease (CVD), possibly through promoting a heightened inflammatory profile. Active stressors are commonly used to investigate cardiovascular and immune reactivity; however, this response may not translate to other stress modalities. We aimed to decipher potential differences in immune responses to passive and active stressors. METHODS: Eighty-eight participants completed this study. After a baseline period, a passive (International Affective Picture System IAPS) and active stress task (Paced Auditory Serial Addition Test PASAT) were completed in a randomized order, with 45-minute rest post-tasks. Cardiovascular measures (including SBP, DBP, HR) were collected continuously. Blood samples were collected after each time point determining inflammatory responses, including circulating and stimulated interleukin-6 (IL-6), systemic inflammation response index (SIRI), neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio (NLR), TNF-α, and P- and E-selectin. RESULTS: Cardiovascular measures were higher during the PASAT than IAPS (p .05). SIRI increased from baseline to post-IAPS (p = .013), 45-minute post-IAPS (p = .004), and 45-minute post-PASAT (p .05). CONCLUSION: Both stressors increased circulating IL-6 levels and SIRI. Cardiovascular measures were higher during the active task, but the magnitude of inflammatory responses did not significantly differ between tasks. Regardless of stress modality, an immune response ensues, potentially increasing the risk of CVD over time.
Linsley et al. (Sat,) reported a rct. Active psychological stress task (PASAT) vs. Passive psychological stress task (IAPS) was evaluated on Difference in circulating IL-6 levels at 45-minutes post-task (p=>0.05). Active psychological stress (PASAT) and passive stress (IAPS) both increased circulating IL-6 and SIRI, with no significant difference in inflammatory response magnitude between tasks (p>0.05).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: