Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
We present a phase-plane analysis of cosmologies containing a scalar field with an exponential potential V (-) where ² = 8 G and V may be positive or negative. We show that power-law kinetic-potential scaling solutions only exist for sufficiently flat (²6) negative potentials. The latter correspond to a class of ever-expanding cosmologies with negative potential. However we show that these expanding solutions with a negative potential are to unstable in the presence of ordinary matter, spatial curvature or anisotropic shear, and generic solutions always recollapse to a singularity. Power-law kinetic-potential scaling solutions are the late-time attractor in a collapsing universe for steep negative potentials (the ekpyrotic scenario) and stable against matter, curvature or shear perturbations. Otherwise kinetic-dominated solutions are the attractor during collapse (the pre big bang scenario) and are only marginally stable with respect to anisotropic shear.
Heard et al. (Tue,) studied this question.