Background Carbonization of woody biomass under inert atmospheres is a practical route to producing functional carbon materials. However, carbon yield and microstructural development are strongly influenced by temperature and by the presence of metal additives. The temperature-dependent differences in the effects of such additives on carbonization behavior remain insufficiently understood. Methods The effects of copper and titanium additives were systematically examined during heat-induced carbonization of Todo fir ( Abies sachalinensis ) wood flour at 500 °C and 800 °C under nitrogen using controlled heating rates. Carbonization behavior was analyzed by thermogravimetric–differential thermal analysis. The resulting char was characterized by elemental analysis, scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy. Results At 500 °C, copper addition was associated with the formation of partially layered turbostratic carbon structures with expanded interlayer spacing, suggesting possible stabilization of carbon frameworks with reduced bond cleavage. In contrast, titanium addition was associated with increased devolatilization and fragmentation, leading to lower carbon retention and more heterogeneous microstructures. At 800 °C, thermally stable, carbon-rich residues were obtained largely independent of heating rate, indicating that the final hold temperature was the primary factor influencing bulk carbon ordering. Under these conditions, copper was associated with higher char retention, whereas titanium was associated with enhanced interfacial reactions and decomposition-related behavior at carbon interfaces. Transmission electron microscopy showed that overall structural ordering was primarily determined by the final temperature rather than by the additive. These findings indicate temperature-dependent variation in additive effects, with copper favoring solid carbon retention at moderate temperatures and titanium showing stronger decomposition-related effects at elevated temperatures. Conclusions The results suggest distinct temperature-dependent differences in the effects of copper and titanium during biomass carbonization and provide a basis for considering additive selection and thermal design in controlling carbon yield and microstructure.
Hata et al. (Sat,) studied this question.