Particle breakage during shearing of a carbonate sand

A series of ring shear tests was conducted to investigate the development of particle breakage with shear strain for a carbonate sand. It was found that at very large displacements the soil reached a stable grading, but that the final grading was dependent on both the applied normal stress and the initial grading. The particle breakage caused a volumetric compression, which again ceased only when the stable grading had been attained, emphasising that critical states as observed at much smaller strains in triaxial tests are not rigorously defined. Despite the severe degradation of the soil particles the mobilised angle of shearing resistance was found not to change significantly.