Key result
A 7-year school-based physical education intervention of 200 minutes per week increased tibial cortical strength (SSI) by 6.9% and improved region-specific cortical bone mass distribution in girls, but had no significant effect in boys.
Why the study?
Does a school-based physical activity intervention improve tibial cortical bone mass distribution in children?
Does a school-based physical activity intervention improve tibial cortical bone mass distribution in children?
Effect estimate: 6.9% greater
Absolute Event Rate: 1787% vs 1672%
p-value: p=0.036
A 7-year school-based physical activity intervention of 200 min/week improved tibial structure and cortical bone mass distribution in girls, but not in boys.
May support more school PE for pediatric bone health; leaves open causal effects on tibial cortical distribution.
Cortical bone mass and density varies across a bones length and cross section, and may be influenced by physical activity. This study evaluated the long-term effects of a pediatric school-based physical activity intervention on tibial cortical bone mass distribution. A total of 170 children (72 girls and 98 boys) from one school were provided with 200 min of physical education per week. Three other schools (44 girls and 47 boys) continued with the standard 60 min per week. Tibial total and cortical area, cortical density, polar stress–strain index (SSI), and the mass and density distribution around the center of mass (polar distribution, mg) and through the bones cortex (radial distribution subdivided into endo-, mid-, and pericortical volumetric BMD: mg/cm 3 ) at three sites (14, 38, and 66 %) were assessed using peripheral quantitative computed tomography after 7 years. Girls in the intervention group had 2.5 % greater cortical thickness and 6.9 % greater SSI at the 66 % tibia, which was accompanied by significantly greater pericortical volumetric BMD compared to controls (all P < 0.05). Region-specific differences in cortical mass were also detected in the anterior, medial, and lateral sectors at the 38 and 66 % tibial sites. There were no group differences at the 14 % tibia site in girls, and no group differences in any of the bone parameters in boys. Additional school-based physical education over seven years was associated with greater tibial structure, strength, and region-specific adaptations in cortical bone mass and density distribution in girls, but not in boys.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fritz et al. (2016) studied Healthy children (n=261). School-based physical education (PE) vs. Standard physical education (60 min per week) was evaluated on Polar stress-strain index (SSI) at the 66% tibia in girls (6.9% greater, p=0.036). A 7-year school-based physical education intervention of 200 minutes per week increased tibial cortical strength (SSI) by 6.9% and improved region-specific cortical bone mass distribution in girls, but had no significant effect in boys.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: