A major discrepancy between Toomre's theory of bar instabilities and recent N-body experiments is resolved. Toomre's prediction that bars ought to be inhibited by a low-mass but dense central bulge is shown to be correct for small amplitude perturbations but it is also demonstrated that such a model is merely meta-stable and will form a bar when subject to a large enough initial perturbation. Density fluctuations arising from tens of thousands of randomly distributed particles in N-body experiments are generally substantial enough to alter the predicted small amplitude behaviour drastically. The different behaviour at finite amplitude is largely attributable to saturation at inner Lindblad resonances.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J. A. Sellwood (1989) studied this question.