Unified analysis reveals effective signal classification through matched transforms in various data types, indicating robust models.
This document consolidates three companion studies into one narrative. A fixed transform, a compaction step that keeps a few principal coordinates, a magnitude/phase feature map and a linear readout form a strong, cheap classifier — when the transform matches the signal's structure. Part I develops this for the Fourier transform and shows that the most effective single improvement is selecting frequencies by discriminative power (ANOVA F-score) rather than energy; that, with parameters counted in full (each complex weight as two reals), the model is competitive with a spiking network at a fraction of the budget; and that the advantage is conditional on spectral structure. Part II repeats the programme with wavelets, adding the key observation that localized wavelet magnitude recovers temporal order a Fourier magnitude hides in phase, while a fully invariant scattering discards it, and that an orthogonal DWT fails on narrow-band global structure. Part III pools the transforms into one dictionary and lets discriminative selection route itself — a reconstruction of the Local Discriminant Basis — and stress-tests it across six source types (1-D localized and global, two image types, text, video) against a deep network. A final component removes the last manual choice — the classifier head — by making it self-organizing: linear by default, growing gated non-linear blocks only where the data demands them, at negligible convergence cost. Throughout, the framing is candid: these are reconstructions and cross-modality validations of classical ideas, with negative results reported as prominently as positive ones.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Juan Carlos del Rio Romero (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: