Key result
Pre-closure checklists identify actionable intraoperative errors in ~10% of cases but fail to reduce complications.
Why the study?
Checklist use during abdominal closure may reduce human error, so the authors evaluated whether implementing an institutional checklist prompted additional procedures.
Does a pre-abdominal closure checklist improve surgical safety in patients undergoing colorectal surgery?
Cohort (n=451)
No
Does a pre-abdominal closure checklist improve surgical safety in patients undergoing colorectal surgery?
A pre-abdominal closure checklist in colorectal surgery facilitated the identification of intraoperative errors requiring additional procedures, though it did not significantly change postoperative complication rates.
May prompt additional procedures without improving outcomes; hypothesis-generating and requires prospective trials before practice change.
The use of a checklist during abdominal closure may reduce human error and improve surgical safety. To address this benefit, we evaluated the effectiveness of an institutional checklist by determining whether implementation led to additional procedures. A 12‑item pre‑closure checklist for colorectal surgery was developed and incorporated into practice in late May 2024. We retrospectively reviewed checklist findings documented in electronic medical records. Surgical outcomes were compared between 42 cases with and 409 cases without checklist use during 2020–2024. Of 45 patients, checklist information was unavailable for three. Among 42 remaining patients, additional intraoperative procedures were required in four cases following checklist use. Procedures included injury repair or hemostasis ( n = 1), application of antiadhesion agents ( n = 2), and repositioning of intestine or omentum to the original position ( n = 1). No incidents involving retained gauze, residual tissue, or deviations from planned procedures were identified. Among four cases requiring additional interventions, two involved multiple ancillary procedures and two required extended operative duration. No significant differences were observed between groups in anastomotic leakage, complication rate, or length of postoperative hospitalization. The pre-closure checklist facilitated the identification of intraoperative errors that otherwise might have been overlooked. Additional studies with a larger patient population, broader range of surgical procedures, and multiple institutions are needed to further clarify its utility.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marui et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Colorectal surgery (n=451). 12-item pre-abdominal closure checklist vs. No checklist was evaluated on Additional intraoperative procedures. A pre-abdominal closure checklist in colorectal surgery identified intraoperative errors requiring additional procedures in 9.5% of cases, with no significant difference in complication rates.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: