Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Urban vegetation mitigates heat through evapotranspiration (ET) and shading, and quantitatively characterizing these two pathways is essential for comparable cross-city assessment and for identifying climate-specific limiting factors. However, a standardized and physically based framework to quantify and compare these cooling effects across different cities and climatic contexts is still lacking. Existing metrics, such as evapotranspiration-induced cooling of vegetation (ECoV) and shading-induced cooling of vegetation (SCoV), are typically applied within individual cities. To address this, we developed a transferable framework that integrates a physically based Soil-Canopy-Observation of Photochemistry and Energy (SCOPE) – Surface Energy Balance (SEB) model for evapotranspiration-related cooling with surface temperature analysis for shading-related cooling. Evapotranspiration-related cooling ( ΔT LE ) is quantified through the SCOPE–SEB framework, whereas shading-related cooling ( ΔT Shade ) is independently derived from surface temperature contrasts, enabling consistent cross-city comparison under extreme heat conditions. We evaluated the model at eddy-covariance flux towers in four mid-latitude cities representing hot-desert (Phoenix, Las Vegas) and Mediterranean (Rome, Florence) climates. The model demonstrated strong performance: turbulent heat fluxes (sensible, H, and latent, LE ) were reconstructed with R 2 = 0.56–0.78, while surface temperature ( T s ) was simulated with R 2 = 0.47–0.95. Modeled aerodynamic resistance showed lower agreement with tower-derived estimates and decreased with increasing wind speed. Crucially, the model achieved robust energy balance closure, with residuals of only ∼3–7%. Specifically, we revealed that: (1) The magnitude of daytime ΔT LE was greater in Mediterranean cities (−1.98 °C) than in hot-desert cities (−1.34 °C), whereas daytime ΔT Shade was significantly stronger in Mediterranean cities (−2.60 °C vs. -0.90 °C). Spatially, deserts exhibited extensive daytime warming patches in ΔT Shade and lower heterogeneity in ΔT LE , contrasting with the widespread, strong cooling and higher intra-urban variability of Mediterranean cities. (2) The primary controls were climate-dependent: cooling in water-limited deserts was dominated by soil moisture and leaf water/chlorophyll content, whereas in Mediterranean cities, canopy structure (height, LAI) governed both ΔT LE and ΔT Shade , with meteorology playing a secondary modulating role. This mechanism-explicit, physically consistent framework provides a transformative tool for cross-city comparison of vegetation-based heat mitigation, enhancing our understanding of climate-dependent ecosystem services.
Yu et al. (Thu,) studied this question.