A Balancing Act: Stability versus Reactivity of Mn(O) Complexes

A large class of heme and non-heme metalloenzymes utilize O2 or its derivatives (e.g., H2O2) to generate high-valent metal-oxo intermediates for performing challenging and selective oxidations. Due to their reactive nature, these intermediates are often short-lived and very difficult to characterize. Synthetic chemists have sought to prepare analogous metal-oxo complexes with ligands that impart enough stability to allow for their characterization and an examination of their inherent reactivity. The challenge in designing these molecules is to achieve a balance between their stability, which should allow for their in situ characterization or isolation, and their reactivity, in which they can still participate in interesting chemical transformations. This Account focuses on our recent efforts to generate and stabilize high-valent manganese-oxo porphyrinoid complexes and tune their reactivity in the oxidation of organic substrates. Dioxygen can be used to generate a high-valent Mn(V)(O) corrolazine (Mn(V)(O)(TBP8Cz)) by irradiation of Mn(III)(TBP8Cz) with visible light in the presence of a C-H substrate. Quantitative formation of the Mn(V)(O) complex occurs with concomitant selective hydroxylation of the benzylic substrate hexamethylbenzene. Addition of a strong H(+) donor converted this light/O2/substrate reaction from a stoichiometric to a catalytic process with modest turnovers. The addition of H(+) likely activates a transient Mn(V)(O) complex to achieve turnover, whereas in the absence of H(+), the Mn(V)(O) complex is an unreactive "dead-end" complex. Addition of anionic donors to the Mn(V)(O) complex also leads to enhanced reactivity, with a large increase in the rate of two-electron oxygen atom transfer (OAT) to thioether substrates. Spectroscopic characterization (Mn K-edge X-ray absorption and resonance Raman spectroscopies) revealed that the anionic donors (X(-)) bind to the Mn(V) ion to form six-coordinate Mn(V)(O)(X)(-) complexes. An unusual "V-shaped" Hammett plot for the oxidation of para-substituted thioanisole derivatives suggested that six-coordinate Mn(V)(O)(X)(-) complexes can act as both electrophiles and nucleophiles, depending on the nature of the substrate. Oxidation of the Mn(V)(O) corrolazine resulted in the in situ generation of a Mn(V)(O) π-radical cation complex, Mn(V)(O)(TBP8Cz(•+))(+), which exhibited more than a 100-fold rate increase in the oxidation of thioethers. The addition of Lewis acids (LA; Zn(II), B(C6F5)3) to the closed-shell, diamagnetic Mn(V)(O)(TBP8Cz) stabilized a paramagnetic valence tautomer Mn(IV)(O)(TBP8Cz(•+))(LA), which was characterized as a second π-radical cation complex by NMR, EPR, UV-vis, and high resolution cold spray ionization MS. The Mn(IV)(O)(TBP8Cz(•+))(LA) complexes are able to abstract H(•) from phenols and exhibit a rate enhancement of up to ∼100-fold over the parent Mn(V)(O) valence tautomer. In contrast, a large decrease in rate is observed for OAT for the Mn(IV)(O)(TBP8Cz(•+))(LA) complexes. The rate enhancement for hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) may derive from the higher redox potential for the π-radical cation complex, while the large rate decrease seen for OAT may come from a decrease in electrophilicity for an Mn(IV)(O) versus Mn(V)(O) complex.