Relationships between Extreme Rain Rates and Convective Intensities from the Perspectives of TRMM and WSR-88D Radars

TRMM PR 2A25, version 7 (V7), retrievals of reflectivity Z and rainfall rate R are compared with WSR-88D dual-polarimetric S-band radar data for 28 radars over the southeastern United States after matching their horizontal resolution and sampling. TRMM Ku-band measurements are converted to S-band approximations to more directly compare reflectivity estimates. Rain rates are approximated from WSR-88D data using the CSU–hydrometeor identification rainfall optimization (HIDRO) algorithm. Tropics-wide TRMM retrievals confirm previous findings of a low overlap fraction between extreme convective intensity, as approximated by the maximum 40-dB Z height, and extreme near-surface rain rates. WSR-88D data also confirm this low overlap but show that it is likely higher than TRMM PR retrievals indicate. For maximum 40-dB Z echo heights that extend above the freezing level, mean WSR-88D reflectivities at low levels are approximately 2 dB higher than TRMM PR reflectivities. Higher WSR-88D-retrieved rain rates for a given low-level reflectivity combine with these higher low-level reflectivities for a given maximum 40-dB Z height to produce rain rates that are approximately double those retrieved by the TRMM PR for maximum 40-dB Z heights that extend above the freezing level. TRMM PR path-integrated attenuation, and WSR-88D specific differential phase, differential reflectivity, and hail fraction indicate that the TRMM PR 2A25 V7 algorithm is possibly misidentifying low–midlevel hail and/or graupel as greater attenuating liquid, or vice versa. This misidentification, coupled with underestimation of path-integrated attenuation caused by nonuniform beamfilling and higher rain rates produced by specific differential phase (KDP)– R than Z – R relationships, results in low-biased 2A25 V7 rain rates in intense convection.