The cause of extreme year class variation in a population of roach, Rutilus rutilus L., from a eutrophic lake in southern England

Investigations into the biology of the roach population at Slapton Ley, Devon, U.K. were carried out between October 1982 and December 1984 and data collected from the lake since 1977 have been re‐analysed to assist interpretation. The roach population has been characterized in recent years by extreme year class variation and a tendency for year classes to alternate in strength. The survival of the roach was very poor, and the spawning population therefore consisted largely of 2‐and some 3‐year‐old fish. Consequently, the size of the spawning stock was small and dependent on the strengths of the year classes that it contained. Recruitment to many year classes was probably limited by the size of the spawning stock. The occurrence of a poor year class in the population would therefore set up an autonomous cycle of poor recruitment to alternate year classes in a manner similar to many tropical marine fisheries. Observation of other British roach populations showed that a short life‐span may be associated with conditions that promote very rapid growth rates. The growth rate of individual roach at Slapton was found to be one of the fastest in Britain, and this was apparently due to the very high productivity of Slapton Ley together with the persistence of the roach population at very low densities.