The genetic structure and microdistribution of shoals of Phoxinus phoxinus, the European minnow

Efficient foraging and a reduction in predation risk have been proposed as reasons for shoal formation. Some behaviours in cyprinid shoals are at first sight altruistic (e.g. predator inspection behaviour, reactions to alarm substance), such that kin selection may have been involved in their evolution. If shoaling behaviour does evolve through kin selection, then genetic differentiation is expected to be greater between shoals than within shoals. Such a hypothesis was tested here by examining shoal integrity and the relatedness of individuals within and between shoals in the European minnow, Phoxinus phoxinus , using nuclear and mitochondrial DNA markers. The breeding structure of 13 minnow shoals collected from Dorset and North Wales, U.K., was examined using allozymes. Genetic affinity within and between shoals was tested using mitochondrial DNA and multi‐locus DNA fingerprinting. Shoals consisted of a random assortment of allozyme genotypes, shoal members did not share the same maternal mtDNA lineages and DNA fingerprint profiles were as varied within shoals as between them. The data indicate that it is unlikely that kin selection occurs in P. phoxinus and there is no apparent relationship between shoaling behaviour and genotype distribution in this species.