Evolution of Structure–Reactivity Correlations for the Hydrogen Abstraction Reaction by Chlorine Atom

Empirical structure-reactivity correlations are developed for log k(298), the gas-phase rate constants for the reaction (Cl(•) + HCR(3) → ClH + CR(3)(•)). It has long been recognized that correlation with Δ(r)H is weak. The poor performance of the linear Evans-Polanyi formulation is illustrated and was little improved by adding a quadratic term, for example, by making its slope smoothly dependent on Δ(r)H [η ≡ (Δ(r)H - Δ(r)H(min))/(Δ(r)H(max) - Δ(r)H(min))]. The "polar effect" ((δ-)Cl---H---CR(3)(δ+))(++) has also been long discussed, but there is no formalization of this dependence based on widely available independent variable(s). Using the sum of Hammett constants for the R substituents also gave at best modest correlations, either for σ(para) or for its dissection into F (field/inductive) and R (resonance) effects. Much greater success was achieved by combining these approaches with the preferred independent variable set being either [(Δ(r)H)(2), Δ(r)H, ΣF, and ΣR] or [η, Δ(r)H, ΣF, and ΣR]. For 64 rate constants that span 7 orders of magnitude, these correlation formulations give r(2) > 0.87 and a mean unsigned deviation of <0.5 log k units, with even better performance if primary, secondary, and tertiary reaction centers are treated separately.