Five-coordinate Mn IV intermediate in the activation of nature’s water splitting cofactor

Significance Recent results have shown that nature’s water splitting catalyst inserts an additional water molecule into what appears to be a solvent inaccessible site late in its reaction cycle. The emerging consensus of the field is that this water molecule is one of the substrates of the reaction. Here, we show that this water molecule does not come directly from solvent. It instead represents an earlier bound water, which is inserted into this site via facile structural tautomerism. The trigger for this process is cofactor oxidation. This then allows an additional water to bind from solvent to a more open site of the cofactor. In this way the cofactor carefully regulates water uptake, preventing water insertion earlier in the reaction cycle.