Radiation resistance, although ordinarily neglected, is actually of dominant importance in determining the selectivity factor Q and the input impedance Zsfor both parallel-wire and concentric lines at high radio frequencies, and therefore materially changes the optimum design of the line, whether used as a low-loss inductive or capacitive reactance or to give high selectivity or high impedance as a resonant line. Accurate design equations for maximum selectivity and for maximum impedance are developed in this paper for both parallel-wire and concentric lines, and curves are included showing radiation resistance, selectivity, input impedance, optimum values of spacing, conductor radius, etc. It is shown that for maximum Q the optimum ratio of spacing to wire radius for parallel-wire lines is D/r = 6.186, and the ratio of outer conductor radius to inner conductor radius for concentric lines is b/a = 4.22, as compared with values of about 3.6 for both ratios when radiation resistance is neglected. For maximum impedance corresponding values are D/r = 20.96 and b/a = 14.3, as compared with values of 8 and 9.2, respectively, predicted neglecting radiation resistance. Moreover, Q and Zsare not proportional to D and b as indicated in previous analyses; instead definite values of D and b give maximum Q and slightly larger values give maximum Zs, and even a small departure from the best value produces a large decrease in Q or in Zs. Q and Zsfor optimum design are both inversely proportional to the cube root of the frequency for parallel-wire lines and inversely proportional to the 0.4 power of the frequency for concentric lines, whereas previous analyses showed both increasing as the square root of the frequency.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lester E. Reukema (1937) studied this question.