Key result
A systematic review of 19 studies found that alternative analgesics like TENS, auricular acupressure, and fascia iliaca compartment block are safe and effective for prehospital femur fractures.
Why the study?
Femur shaft and neck of femur fractures are often undertreated and present unique clinical and logistical concerns in the prehospital setting.
What interventions are effective for paramedic prehospital pain management of patients with neck of femur or femur shaft fractures?
Systematic Review (n=19)
What interventions are effective for paramedic prehospital pain management of patients with neck of femur or femur shaft fractures?
Alternative analgesics such as TENS, auricular acupressure, and fascia iliaca compartment block are emerging as safe and effective options for prehospital pain management of femur fractures by paramedics.
Supports broader prehospital analgesia protocols for femur fractures; extends Level 1 evidence for non-opioid alternatives.
Femur shaft and neck of femur (NOF) fractures are often undertreated in the prehospital setting. These injuries can present unique clinical and logistical concerns in the prehospital setting. This systematic review aimed to investigate paramedic prehospital pain management of patients who had suffered NOF or femur fractures, and to investigate which interventions are effective. A systematic review was conducted in line with Preferred Reporting Item for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Four databases were searched from inception date 23 March 2020. Articles were independently reviewed by two authors and conflicts resolved by a third author, followed by a hand search of the included reference lists. References were included if they addressed paramedic interventions for NOF or femur shaft fractures. Outcomes of interest were the effectiveness and complications of different modalities administered by paramedics. The search yielded 6868 articles, of which 19 met the final inclusion criteria. Studies investigated a variety of interventions including traction splints, intravenous (IV) analgesia and alternative analgesic options. Traction splinting and IV analgesia were consistently reported as underutilised. Alternative analgesics such as auricular acupressure, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) and fascia iliaca compartment block were found to be effective techniques that could be safely and competently employed by paramedics, reducing pain for patients with limited adverse events. NOF and femur shaft fractures are an undertreated injury in the prehospital setting. Traction splinting and IV analgesia remain the traditional methodologies of treatment for these injuries; however, there are alternatives such as TENS, auricular acupressure and fascia iliaca compartment block that appear to be emerging as safe and effective options for the prehospital setting.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Davis et al. (2021) conducted a systematic review in Neck of femur (NOF) or femur shaft fractures (n=19). Paramedic prehospital pain management interventions was evaluated on Effectiveness and complications of different modalities administered by paramedics. A systematic review of 19 studies found that alternative analgesics like TENS, auricular acupressure, and fascia iliaca compartment block are safe and effective for prehospital femur fractures.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: