In three-dimensional Bénard convection regions of rising and sinking fluid are dissimilar. This geometrical effect is studied for axisymmetric convection in a Boussinesq fluid contained in a cylindrical cell with free boundaries. Near the critical Rayleigh number R c the solution is obtained from a perturbation expansion, valid only if both the Reynolds number and the Péclet number are small. For values of the Nusselt number N ≤ 2 accurate solutions are provided by an expansion in a finite number of vertical modes. For Prandtl numbers p < 1 the form of the solution changes at large Reynolds number and becomes independent of p ; in the limit p → 0 there is an effective critical Rayleigh number R * = 1.32 R c , which can also be derived by a perturbation procedure, and the Nusselt number is a function of the Rayleigh number only. Numerical experiments yield solutions for Rayleigh numbers R ≤ 100 R c and p ≥ 0.01. The results are similar to those for two-dimensional rolls and for R ≥ 5 R c the Nusselt number shows only a weak dependence on p . For p > 1 there is a viscous regime with N ≈ 2( R / R c ) 1/3 ; when R / R c [gsim ] p 3/2 , N increases more rapidly, approximately as R 0.4 . At high Rayleigh numbers a large isothermal region develops, in which the ratio of vorticity to distance from the axis is nearly constant.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jones et al. (1976) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: