Key result
Cycle exercise at 65% VO2R was associated with a significantly greater delay of postexercise heart rate variability recovery compared to treadmill exercise in apparently healthy men.
Why the study?
Does cycle exercise compared to treadmill exercise delay postexercise heart rate variability recovery in apparently healthy men?
RCT (n=14)
Randomized days
Does cycle exercise compared to treadmill exercise delay postexercise heart rate variability recovery in apparently healthy men?
Cycle exercise at 65% VO2R is associated with a greater delay in postexercise heart rate variability recovery compared to treadmill exercise at the same relative intensity in healthy men.
Account for modality in postexercise HRV assessment; extends RCT evidence on autonomic recovery differences.
Summary The purpose of this study was to compare postexercise heart rate variability (HRV) immediately following acute bouts of treadmill (T) and cycle (C) exercise at 65% of mode‐specific maximal oxygen consumption reserve (65% VO2R). Fourteen apparently healthy men participated in this study. On two separate and randomized days, each participant performed 30 min of exercise at 65% VO2R on T and C. Supine HRV was evaluated as normalized and log‐transformed (ln) high‐frequency (HF) and low‐frequency (LF) spectral power, as well as the LF:HF ratio in 5‐min segments immediately before (PRE) and at 10–15 min (POST1) and 25–30 min (POST2) following each exercise bout. There were no significant differences in the HRV values at PRE between the modalities. Following each exercise bout, lnHF was significantly lower at POST2 following C compared to T. In addition, lnLF and LF:HF were significantly higher at POST1 and POST2 following C compared to T. All HRV metrics returned towards baseline 30 min following T but remained significantly different than PRE values after C. These results suggest that following exercise at 65% of mode‐specific VO2R, C is associated with a greater delay of postexercise HRV recovery than T in apparently healthy men.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Esco et al. (2015) conducted an RCT in Apparently healthy (n=14). Cycle exercise vs. Treadmill exercise was evaluated on Postexercise heart rate variability (HRV) recovery. Cycle exercise at 65% VO2R was associated with a significantly greater delay of postexercise heart rate variability recovery compared to treadmill exercise in apparently healthy men.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: