Phylogenetic relationships in Monanthes (Crassulaceae) based on morphological, chloroplast and nuclear DNA variation

Phylogenetic relationships of all 10 recognized taxa of the genus Monanthes which is endemic to the Canary Islands and Salvage Islands, were investigated using the four data sets: morphology, sequences of the chloroplast DNA trnL (UAA) — trnF (GAA) intergenic spacer, ITS2 sequences of the nuclear ribosomal region and Random Amplified Polymorphic DNAs (RAPDs). In contrast to the molecular data, the morphological data were internally inconsistent which probably resulted from parallel or convergent evolution of morphological characters. The molecular data sets indicated that the genus is not monophyletic due to inclusion of the annual M. icterica which is the putative sister taxon of Aichryson, that M. polyphylla is the sister taxon of the perennial species of the genus, that M. muralis from Hierro is of allotetraploid origin and that M. lowei, M. minima, M. brachycaulos, M. laxiflora, M. anagensis and M. muralis from La Palma are closely related. Combined ITS2 sequences, trnL — trnF sequences and morphological data indicated that the relationships among three types of perennial growth forms, i.e. tiny rosettes, small, branched shrubs and diffuse branches shrublets, are highly dependent on the outgroup used. After deletion of the most distant outgroup and a taxon of alleged hybrid origin (M. muralis) relationships among the growth forms of Monanthes still could not be consistently resolved.