Key result
Prophylactic anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin resulted in virologically confirmed CMV disease in 37% of treated renal transplant patients, compared to 33% in historical controls without prophylaxis.
Why the study?
Does anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin prevent CMV disease in seronegative renal transplant patients receiving organs from seropositive donors?
RCT (n=45)
randomized
Does anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin prevent CMV disease in seronegative renal transplant patients receiving organs from seropositive donors?
Prophylactic anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin did not appear to reduce the incidence of CMV disease compared to historical controls in seronegative renal transplant recipients from seropositive donors.
Anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin prophylaxis does not lower CMV disease rates; challenges routine use and leaves open optimal prevention strategies in D+/R- renal transplants.
Cytomegalovirus (CMV) causes marked morbidity in renal transplant patients which may be prevented by passive immunization. We studied the effect of two different hyperimmune globulins in the prevention of CMV disease in seronegative patients receiving renal transplants from seropositive donors. Thirty patients were randomized to receive either anti‐CMV i.v. Ig (pH 4‐pepsin treated), or CytotectR (beta‐propiolactone treated) 1.5 ml/kg on day 1, 1.0 mg/kg on d 14 and 28, 0.5 ml/kg on d 42, 56, 84 and 112 post‐transplantation. As controls, 15 patients transplanted without CMV prophylaxis immediately before (12 patients) and after (3 patients) the randomization period, were included. All patients and controls received same basic immunosuppression and sulfa‐trimethoprime prophylaxis. Of the 30 patients on prophylactic anti‐CMV globulin, 21 (70%) became CMV‐positive and 11 patients (37%) developed virologically confirmed CMV disease. Two additional patients had fever without other signs of CMV disease. Two patients developed interstitial pneumonitis (IPn). Eleven (37%) patients developed acute rejection and had symptomatic CMV disease after transplantation. CMV disease developed earlier in patients treated for rejection with antithymocyte globulin (ATG) than in patients treated with methylprednisolone. In the historical control group, 5 patients (33%) developed CMV disease and 1 of them had pneumonitis. Seven patients (47%) underwent episodes of acute rejection and 3 of them had CMV disease at the same time. There were no opportunistic infections in cither group.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P Häyry (1992) conducted an RCT in CMV disease in renal transplant patients (n=45). anti-CMV hyperimmune globulins (anti-CMV i.v. Ig or CytotectR) vs. no CMV prophylaxis (historical controls) was evaluated on virologically confirmed CMV disease. Prophylactic anti-CMV hyperimmune globulin resulted in virologically confirmed CMV disease in 37% of treated renal transplant patients, compared to 33% in historical controls without prophylaxis.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: