Key result
Qi Gong practice showed no significant overall improvements in heart rate variability, likely due to significant data heterogeneity across the included studies.
Why the study?
Does Qi Gong improve heart rate variability in heterogeneous populations?
Systematic Review (n=334)
Does Qi Gong improve heart rate variability in heterogeneous populations?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While Qi Gong is a meditative exercise that may influence the autonomic nervous system, current evidence is too heterogeneous to confirm a significant improvement in heart rate variability.
Qì Gōng is a type of exercise that involves meditation and is used for health. With a background from the martial arts, it is known also as an auto healing exercise with three main elements according to Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM): body focus (posture and movement), breathing and mind focus (meditative elements). Heart rate variability is a tool that allows us to measure the autonomic system velocity to detect and respond to unexpected stimuli. So our goal was to build a systematic review of Qi Gong and Heart rate variability. PUBMED, EBSCO and Science Direct data bases were searched. Key terms (MeSH) were Heart Rate Variability and Ch’i Kung OR Qi Gong with a 10-year filter. Four independent reviewers analyzed all articles and excluded duplicated articles, articles in Chinese and articles with no adherence to the subject. The end result was 5 studies selected. Our results showed no significant improvements in HRV with the practice of Qì Gōng, probably because of data heterogeneity. We found 5 types of Qì Gōng, 3 different instruments and different time intervals to measure HRV and 2 different age groups in the studies. We can conclude that there is evidence that Qì Gōng can improve HRV but studies that would use the same parameters are needed to further confirm that.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ramos et al. (2017) conducted a systematic review in Autonomic control / Heart Rate Variability (n=334). Qi Gong vs. Control group or pre-intervention baseline was evaluated on Heart Rate Variability (HRV). Qi Gong practice showed no significant overall improvements in heart rate variability, likely due to significant data heterogeneity across the included studies.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: