Donor and Acceptor Properties of the Chromium Tricarbonyl Substituent in Benzylic and Homobenzylic Anions, Cations, and Radicals

Both benzylic cations and anions are strongly stabilized by chromium tricarbonyl complexation, while benzylic radicals are largely unaffected. Density functional theory calculations were performed on primary, secondary, and tertiary benzylic species to explore the effect of substitution on the stabilizing ability of the chromium tricarbonyl moiety. Complexed 1-indanyl species were also examined to elucidate the effect of conformational restraint. It was found that the strong stabilization of benzylic anions and the slight destabilization of benzylic radicals by chromium tricarbonyl are insensitive to skeletal changes. Chromium-complexed benzylic cations, however, are highly sensitive to changes in the organic framework, with increased substitution or constriction of conformational mobility eroding the effect of the metal. 2-Indanyl species were also examined to study the effect of the chromium tricarbonyl fragment on homobenzylic species. It was found that the metal fragment stabilizes distant anions by field and inductive effects and cations by a direct interaction of the metal with the cationic carbon. Homobenzylic radicals, however, do not interact with the chromium tricarbonyl moiety and suffer a slight inductive destabilization.