Comparison of the orders of gas-phase basicities and ammonium ion affinities of polyethers by the kinetic method and ligand exchange technique

The orders of relative gas-phase basicities and ammonium ion affinities of a series of polyethers obtained by application of the kinetic method and ligand exchange technique are compared to evaluate the discrepancies of results between the two techniques. The order of gas-phase basicities determined by the ligand exchange technique in a quadrupole ion trap agrees with the order established previously by Kebarle using equilibrium methods in a high-pressure mass spectrometer. The order obtained by the kinetic method in a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer varies for the ranking of one polyether (12-crown-4), and this discrepancy is attributed to a difference in the rates of the competing dissociation pathways from the triethylene glycol dimethyl ether/12-crown4 proton-bound adduct, owing to a substantial variation in the flexibilities of these two ethers. For the order of gas-phase ammonium ion affinities, the kinetic method results agree overall with the ligand exchange results; however, the order of ammonium ion affinities for tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether and 15-crown-5 could not be differentiated by the ligand exchange method because of the rapidity of ammonium ion transfer between the two polyethers in both directions.