Composite soil samples from Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin were analyzed for total sulphur, total phosphorus, and volatile matter (loss on ignition), and cooperative fertilizer experiments with gypsum were conducted in fields in Indiana and Kentucky. 2. The analytical data show a general relation between the sulphur content and loss on ignition in soil samples from the same soil type or closely related soil types, but the relation is not apparent when different soil types are compared. 3. The sulphur contents in the surface soil vary from 0.0118 to 0.0905 per cent, while the phosphorus contents vary from 0.0360 to 0.3407 per cent. All the upland soils and most of the alluvial soils are low in sulphur. Most of the Kentucky soils and one of the Indiana soils are high in phosphorus. This is undoubtedly due to the influence of the rock from which the soils were formed, as all the Kentucky samples were from soils derived either from the Trenton limestone or the Cincinnati limestone, both of which are high in phosphorus content. 4. The sulphur and phosphorus contents were calculated to pounds per acre in the surface soil, and compared with the amounts of sulphur and phosphorus removed by maximum crops of corn, wheat, timothy, clover, and alfalfa. The highest sulphur content is sufficient for only 39 years of alfalfa, 139 of clover, 159 of timothy, 355 of wheat, or 232 of corn; while the lowest sulphur content is sufficient for only 5 years of alfalfa, 18 of clover, 21 of timothy, 46 of wheat, or 30 of corn. The lowest phosphorus content is equal to the amount removed by 42 years of corn, 60 of wheat, 80 of timothy, 36 of clover, or 20 of alfalfa. On the other hand, it would take 401 years of corn, 568 of wheat, 757 of timothy, 341 of clover, or 189 of alfalfa to remove as much phosphorus as is found in the soil with the highest phosphorus content. 5. On some of the soils tobacco, clover, and alfalfa have been benefited by the use of gypsum. The results, however, are not quantitative. More field experiments are needed and greater care should be taken to eliminate other factors as far as possible. Each treatment should be replicated to reduce the probable error.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John Woodard (1922) studied this question.