In the presence of conflicting gaze cues, fearful expression and eye-size guide attention

Joshua M. Carlsona* & Jacob Adayba Department of Psychological Science, Northern Michigan University, Marquette, MI, USAb Department of Psychology, Central Michigan University, Mount Pleasant, MI, USA CONTACT Joshua M. Carlson joshcarl@nmu.edu Supplemental data for this article can be accessed here https://doi.org/10.1080/02699931.2017.1391065ABSTRACTHumans are social beings that often interact in multi-individual environments. As such, we are frequently confronted with nonverbal social signals, including eye-gaze direction, from multiple individuals. Yet, the factors that allow for the prioritisation of certain gaze cues over others are poorly understood. Using a modified conflicting gaze paradigm, we tested the hypothesis that fearful gaze would be favoured amongst competing gaze cues. We further hypothesised that this effect is related to the increased sclera exposure, which is characteristic of fearful expressions. Across three experiments, we found that fearful, but not happy, gaze guides observers’ attention over competing non-emotional gaze. The guidance of attention by fearful gaze appears to be linked to increased sclera exposure. However, differences in sclera exposure do not prioritise competing gazes of other types. Thus, fearful gaze guides attention among competing cues and this effect is facilitated by increased sclera exposure – but increased sclera exposure per se does not guide attention. The prioritisation of fearful gaze over non-emotional gaze likely represents an adaptive means of selectively attending to survival-relevant spatial locations.