Key result
Pre-fracture functional scores (Barthel-20, Barthel-100, and new mobility score) validly predicted mortality, residential status, and independent walking ability at 4 months post-fracture.
Why the study?
Do pre-fracture functional level assessment instruments predict 4-month outcomes in older hip fracture patients?
Cohort (n=165)
Do pre-fracture functional level assessment instruments predict 4-month outcomes in older hip fracture patients?
Pre-fracture Barthel-20 and new mobility scores are valid predictors of 4-month outcomes in older hip fracture patients.
May aid early prognostication after hip fracture; supports validation but leaves open impact on care.
Background and purpose - Pre-fracture functional level has been shown to be a consistent predictor of rehabilitation outcomes in older hip fracture patients. We validated 4 overall pre-fracture functional level assessment instruments in patients aged 65 or more, used the prediction of outcome at 4 months post-fracture, and assessed cutoff values for decision making in treatment and rehabilitation. Patients and methods - 165 consecutive patients with acute primary hip fracture were prospectively included in the study. Pre-fracture Barthel-20, Barthel-100, cumulated ambulation score, and new mobility score were scored immediately after admission. Outcome defined as mortality, residential status, and independent walking ability was assessed at 4 months. Results - 3 of the assessment instruments, namely Barthel-20, Barthel-100, and new mobility score, correlated with outcome at 4 months post-fracture and were valid predictors. Thresholds were estimated. We found no evidence that Barthel-100, with its finer granularity, performs better than Barthel-20 as a predictor. Interpretation - Our findings indicate that pre-fracture scores of Barthel-20 and new mobility score have predictive ability, and further investigation of usage for guidance of clinical and rehabilitation decisions concerning hip fracture patients is warranted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tonny Jæger Pedersen (2016) conducted a cohort in acute primary hip fracture (n=165). Pre-fracture functional level assessment (Barthel-20, Barthel-100, cumulated ambulation score, new mobility score) was evaluated on Mortality, residential status, and independent walking ability at 4 months. Pre-fracture functional scores (Barthel-20, Barthel-100, and new mobility score) validly predicted mortality, residential status, and independent walking ability at 4 months post-fracture.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: