The Efficacy of Patient-Controlled Analgesia in Patients Recovering From Flank Incisions

We report on 13 patients undergoing flank incisions in whom the postoperative pain was managed with a patient-controlled analgesia device. An initial group of 7 patients was used to determine the optimal injection dose for each patient and to examine variability in narcotic requirement during the postoperative course. A progressive decrease in narcotic need was noted during the postoperative course with patient-controlled analgesia, resulting in excellent patient acceptance, no postoperative complications and no drug-seeking behavior. A second group of 10 patients was randomized prospectively to receive either patient-controlled analgesia or a standard regimen of intramuscular morphine sulfate. Based on nursing observations, an analgesia and sedation scale was developed that compared the 2 groups. Analysis of a questionnaire evaluating subjective perception of postoperative pain revealed significantly less pain, less sedation and greater activity among patients randomized to patient-controlled analgesia (95 per cent confidence limit).