Key result
Intraoperative nerve monitoring during minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy resulted in a non-significant 26% absolute reduction in vocal cord palsy compared to a historical cohort (33.3% vs 59%, p=0.08).
Why the study?
The study was conducted to demonstrate the safety, efficacy, and feasibility of intraoperative monitoring of the recurrent laryngeal nerves during thoracoscopic and robotic 3-field esophagectomies.
Does intraoperative nerve monitoring reduce vocal cord paresis in patients undergoing minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy?
Cohort (n=68)
No
Does intraoperative nerve monitoring reduce vocal cord paresis in patients undergoing minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy?
Absolute Risk Reduction: 26
Absolute Event Rate: 33.3% vs 59%
Absolute Risk Reduction: 26%
p-value: p=0.08
Intraoperative nerve monitoring during minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy is feasible and may reduce the rate of recurrent laryngeal nerve palsies, though the reduction was not statistically significant in this small cohort.
Purpose To demonstrate the safety, efficacy and feasibility of intraoperative monitoring of the recurrent laryngeal nerves during thoracoscopic and robotic 3-field esophagectomies. Methods This is a retrospective analysis of our initial experience with intra operative nerve monitoring during minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomies. Data were obtained from a prospectively maintained database and electronic medical records. To compare outcomes between IONM and non IONM group Fischer’s exact test was used. All patients underwent a minimally invasive(VATS/Robotic) transthoracic esoohagectomy with a neck anastomosis (McKeown procedure). Intraoperative nerve monitoring was carried out under general anesthesia with assisted ventilation and avoiding use of neuromuscular blockers during the period of nerve monitoring. Results 24 patients underwent nerve monitoring during minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy. 15 patients were operated thoraco-laparosopically and 9 patients underwent a robotic-assisted procedure. 8/24 (33.3%) patients had vocal cord paresis in the immediate post op period. When we compared this to a historical cohort operated in the preceding 5 years in the same institution, we demonstrated a 26% reduction in nerve palsy rate(p-0.08). On follow-up, 6/8 patients reported returning to a normal voice. Conclusions Intra-operative neuro monitoring (IONM) is feasible during minimally invasive 3- field esophagectomy. Using this can potentially lead to a reduced rate of recurrent nerve palsies and a higher nodal yield.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gopinath et al. (2022) conducted a cohort in Esophageal cancer (n=68). Intraoperative nerve monitoring vs. No intraoperative nerve monitoring (historical cohort) was evaluated on Vocal cord paresis/palsy (26% reduction, p=0.08). Intraoperative nerve monitoring during minimally invasive 3-field esophagectomy resulted in a non-significant 26% absolute reduction in vocal cord palsy compared to a historical cohort (33.3% vs 59%, p=0.08).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: