Key result
Structured personal interviews alter nursing admissions by denying paper-appropriate applicants to include other candidates.
Why the study?
Does the inclusion of structured personal interviews improve admission decisions for accelerated second-degree baccalaureate nursing students compared to paper portfolio criteria alone?
Does the inclusion of structured personal interviews improve admission decisions for accelerated second-degree baccalaureate nursing students compared to paper portfolio criteria alone?
Structured personal interviews can alter admission decisions in nursing programs by identifying factors not apparent in paper portfolios.
Interviews may reveal nonacademic traits missed by paper criteria; leaves open whether they improve selection of accelerated nursing students.
Accelerated undergraduate nursing programs have attracted more qualified applicants than can be accommodated, yet higher-than-desired attrition rates continue for a variety of reasons (e.g., pace of program, poor lifestyle choices, role concerns). The financial effects of the loss of students from these programs has gone largely undocumented and is intensified by the knowledge that a better admission decision could have resulted in another nurse in the workforce. In this article, the inclusion of structured personal interviews into the admission decision-making process is discussed. Specifically, do interviews provide relevant data in making admission decisions? Attempts to reduce subjectivity through the development of a structured interview guide, the training of paired interview teams, and the institution of a "post-mortem" technique to guide revisions are also described. Interviews do result in denial of applicants who seem appropriate based on paper portfolio criteria, allowing for inclusion of other potentially successful applicants.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rosenberg et al. (2007) studied Nursing student admissions. Structured personal interviews vs. Paper portfolio criteria was evaluated on Admission decisions. Structured personal interviews for nursing program admissions resulted in the denial of applicants who seemed appropriate based on paper criteria, allowing inclusion of other candidates.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: