Key result
Carvedilol lowers BP similarly to prazosin but additionally reduces HR, confirming alpha-1 and beta blockade.
Why the study?
Does carvedilol demonstrate alpha 1-blocking properties compared to prazosin in patients with mild essential hypertension?
RCT (n=8)
Double-blind
randomized crossover
Does carvedilol demonstrate alpha 1-blocking properties compared to prazosin in patients with mild essential hypertension?
Carvedilol demonstrates clinically significant alpha-1 blocking effects in addition to beta-blockade, which are maintained during chronic administration.
Supports carvedilol for dual alpha-beta blockade in mild hypertension; confirms alpha-1 effects persist during chronic administration.
Carvedilol is a beta-adrenergic-blocking drug with vasodilating properties. This vasodilation has been ascribed to alpha 1-adrenergic blockade, but it has never been shown in the clinical setting. We addressed this issue by studying eight patients with mild essential hypertension who were given prazosin, 2 mg or carvedilol, 25 mg p.o. following a 2-week washout from previous treatment, according to a randomized double-blind, crossover experimental design. Before and 2 h after the administration of either prazosin or carvedilol, the patients were infused i.v. with increasing doses of phenylephrine (0.2-1.2 microgram/kg/min) and isoproterenol (0.01-0.05 microgram/kg/min). The patients were thereafter maintained on carvedilol 25 mg daily for 3 weeks, and the i.v. phenylephrine and isoproterenol infusions were repeated 2 h after the last tablet administration. The results showed that the single dose of carvedilol and prazosin lowered blood pressure (beat-to-beat finger pressure measurement) to a similar extent, but that heart rate was unaffected by prazosin and reduced by carvedilol. The tachycardic response to isoproterenol was abolished by carvedilol and unaffected by prazosin, whereas the pressor response to phenylephrine was reduced by carvedilol and virtually abolished by prazosin. The antihypertensive, beta-blocking and alpha 1-adrenergic-blocking effects of carvedilol were unchanged following prolonged administration of the drug. Thus, at a clinically effective dose, carvedilol not only has beta- but also sizeable alpha 1-blocking effects. These effects are preserved during prolonged administration of the drug. For a comparable antihypertensive action, however, the alpha 1-blocking effect is less pronounced than that of an alpha 1-blocker such as prazosin.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Giannattasio et al. (1992) conducted an RCT in mild essential hypertension (n=8). Carvedilol vs. Prazosin 2 mg was evaluated on Blood pressure, heart rate, and responses to phenylephrine and isoproterenol. Carvedilol 25 mg lowered blood pressure similarly to prazosin 2 mg but also reduced heart rate and abolished the tachycardic response to isoproterenol, confirming its alpha-1 and beta-blocking effects.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: