Key result
ED modified shock index >1.7 predicts admission and a ~5-fold higher likelihood of in-hospital mortality.
Why the study?
The modified shock index (MSI) is used as a predictive marker in various diseases, but the optimal MSI cut-off for predicting admission and in-hospital mortality in emergency department patients was not established.
Does a modified shock index (MSI) > 1.7 predict hospital admission and in-hospital mortality in adult emergency department patients?
Observational (n=567,994,402)
Yes
Does a modified shock index (MSI) > 1.7 predict hospital admission and in-hospital mortality in adult emergency department patients?
An initial modified shock index >1.7 in undifferentiated ED patients is a clinically significant predictor of hospital admission and in-hospital mortality.
Introduction: The modified shock index (MSI) is the ratio of heart rate to mean arterial pressure. It is used as a predictive and prognostic marker in a variety of disease states. This study aimed to derive the optimal MSI cut-off that is associated with increased likelihood (likelihood ratio, LR) of admission and in-hospital mortality in patients presenting to emergency department (ED). Methods: We retrospectively reviewed data from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey between 2005 and 2010. Adults>18 years of age were included regardless of chief complaint. Basic patient demographics, initial vital signs, and outcomes were recorded for each patient. Then the optimal MSI cut-off for prediction of admission and in-hospital mortality in ED was calculated. LR ≥ 5 was considered clinically significant. Results: 567,994,402 distinct weighted adult ED patient visits were included in the analysis. 15.7% and 2.4% resulted in admissions and in-hospital mortality, respectively. MSI > 1.7 was associated with a moderate increase in the likelihood of both admission (Positive LR (+LR) = 6.29) and in-hospital mortality (+LR = 5.12). +LR for hospital admission at MSI >1.7 was higher for men (7.13; 95% CI 7.11-7.15) compared to women (5.49; 95% CI 5.47-5.50) and for non-white (7.92; 95% CI 7.88-7.95) compared to white patients (5.85; 95% CI 5.84-5.86). For MSI <0.7, the +LRs were not clinically significant for admission (+LR = 1.07) or in-hospital mortality (LR = 0.75). Conclusion: In this largest retrospective study, to date, on MSI in the undifferentiated ED population, we demonstrated that an MSI >1.7 on presentation is predictive of admission and in-hospital mortality. The use of MSI could help guide accurate acuity designation, resource allocation, and disposition.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hamade et al. (2023) conducted an observational in Emergency department presentation (n=567,994,402). Modified shock index (MSI) > 1.7 vs. MSI < 0.7 was evaluated on Admission and in-hospital mortality (+LR 6.29 for admission, +LR 5.12 for mortality). A modified shock index >1.7 on ED presentation was predictive of admission (+LR 6.29) and in-hospital mortality (+LR 5.12) across 567 million weighted adult visits.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: