De novo prediction of the ground state structure of transition metal complexes using semiempirical and ab initio quantum mechanics. Coordination isomerism

The ground state coordination isomers for 30 different trigonal bipyramidal transition metal complexes have been predicted using different levels of quantum mechanics: semiempirical (PM3(tm)), ab initio (MP2//HF), pure (BPW91) and hybrid (B3PW91) density functional theory (DFT) methods. For species where these methods failed to reproduce crystallographic data, hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) methods were used to study more exact experimental models. Literature deficiencies regarding ground state multiplicity of these species were supplemented by spin predictions using previously tested PM3(tm) methods. Geometry optimization calculations were performed for each possible coordination isomer. The predicted ground state minima provided by the different methods are compared to each other and with crystallographic data. Pure DFT functionals outperformed hybrid functionals and MP2//HF. The very rapid PM3(tm) parameterization method provided accurate predictions in comparison to other levels of theory. An integrated MM/PM3(tm)/DFT de novo scheme accurately reproduced crystallographic data for species where the individual methods failed.